Search Climate Insights Directory

The document details a seminar on the recall of President Thabo Mbeki by the ANC, arguing that the move was primarily intended to ensure party unity rather than being solely about legal implications. It assesses the stability of South Africa's economic and foreign policies under the subsequent administration of President Motlanthe and examines the constitutionality of the 'recall' process. Additionally, it considers the impact of Mbeki's departure on his role as a mediator in African conflicts.

The document reports on a September 2008 seminar discussing how international criminal justice, anchored by the ICC, interacts with the African Peace and Security Architecture (APSA). Participants debated the 'peace-justice nexus,' arguing that while tensions can exist, retributive and restorative justice should be pursued simultaneously to remove threats to security. The discussions highlighted that the ICC can provide a 'win-win dividend' for APSA by addressing institutional deficiencies in the 'African solutions to African problems' approach, serving as a non-violent alternative to the use of force.

The document reports on a seminar led by Dr. Witold Patoka regarding the August 2008 war in Georgia. It details the conflict's start on August 7, the subsequent ceasefire arranged by French President Nicolas Sarkozy on August 12, and the strategic importance of Georgia's energy transit infrastructure. The seminar analyzed how Georgia's aspirations for EU and NATO membership, combined with US military assistance and the Baku-Tblisi-Ceyhan pipeline, strained relations with Russia and impacted European security. The event also featured a Russian delegation that contested the narrative, asserting South Ossetia's independence and blaming Georgia for the conflict.

The report details the results of Angola's first elections in 16 years, noting a landslide victory for the MPLA. It identifies systemic failures in the electoral process, including logistical issues in Luanda and media manipulation, while highlighting the fragmentation of opposition parties. The document also addresses broader threats to sustainable peace, such as ineffective disarmament, demobilization, and reintegration (DDR) and widespread poverty.

The report analyzes the 2008 border dispute between Eritrea and Djibouti, tracing its roots to colonial-era protocols from 1900 and 1901. It argues that the conflict is not primarily about the contested Ras Doumeirah area, but is a strategic move by Eritrea to pressure Ethiopia, which relies heavily on Djibouti's ports. The document details the military imbalance between the two states, the role of external actors like France and the US, and the broader instability in the Horn of Africa, including proxy wars in Somalia and internal tensions in Ethiopia's Ogaden region.

On 8 September 2008, the Institute for Security Studies (ISS) and the Southern African Development Community Parliamentary Forum (SADC PF) signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU). The agreement focuses on cooperation regarding parliamentary professional development, capacity building, and the oversight of security sector governance. Specifically, the two organizations will provide training for parliamentarians, support staff, and parliamentary committees on the development of national security and defence policies and the general workings of the security sector.

The document presents a detailed table of United Nations personnel fatalities from 1948 to June 2008. It categorizes deaths into those under the Department of Peacekeeping Operations (DPKO), non-DPKO missions (special political or peacebuilding field missions), and general peacekeeping fatalities. The data shows a total of 2,482 fatalities over the period, with the highest annual death tolls occurring in 1961, 1993, and the early 2000s.

The document examines the fight against corruption in the South African Department of Correctional Services (DCS). It highlights the success of the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) and the Departmental Investigating Unit (DIU) in recovering funds and securing convictions, but warns that these investigative successes are undermined by a lack of sustained disciplinary action by management and a failure to address 'petty corruption' affecting prisoners. The author argues for a holistic strategy combining investigation with prevention, public awareness, and institutional building to change the organizational culture.

The Pan-African Parliament (PAP), inaugurated in 2004, currently operates as a consultative and advisory body without legislative, supervisory, or budgetary powers. The document argues that the PAP's institutional weakness stems from the decision by African leaders in 1999 to accelerate its establishment, bypassing the gradual six-stage integration process outlined in the 1991 Abuja Treaty. This premature launch left the PAP without necessary foundations, resulting in a 'disconnection between reality and the expectation' of its contribution to the African Union (AU). Key challenges include poor interaction with other AU organs, a lack of control over its own budget, and a membership system based on nomination from national legislatures rather than direct election by citizens. While the PAP has conducted observer missions to regions such as Darfur, Mauritania, the DRC, and the Central African Republic, many of its resolutions are ignored by the AU executive. The author suggests that the PAP must exploit existing protocol provisions to enhance its visibility and engagement with AU organs to become a relevant institution.

The document examines the transition of South Africa's juvenile justice system from a punitive, retributive model toward a restorative approach. It details the influence of international instruments like the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child and analyzes the Child Justice Bill's mechanisms for raising the age of criminal capacity, implementing mandatory assessments, and prioritizing diversion over detention.

The seminar analyzed the Pan-African Parliament's (PAP) efforts to uphold democratic principles in Africa, noting that many elections serve as a "façade for democracy within semi-authoritarian systems." Participants discussed the limitations of the PAP as a consultative body and the need to transition from short-term election observation to long-term monitoring and supervision. The report emphasizes the necessity of a common code of conduct for observers and the importance of professional, non-partisan parliamentarians to ensure credible elections.

The report examines the Niger Delta crisis, arguing that the transition from a regional to a federal control of oil revenue after 1956, combined with environmental degradation by oil multinationals and state failure in governance, led to systemic instability. It identifies a 30% loss in daily oil production due to militant attacks and recommends environmental assessments, community compensation, and inclusive dialogue to achieve peace.

The document identifies internal factors contributing to Mauritania's political crisis, including a lack of democratic political culture, ethnic marginalization, and corruption. External influences are attributed to transnational Islamist phenomena. Proposed solutions include the creation of a non-politicized army, an independent judiciary, and the inclusion of ethnic minorities in decision-making processes.

The document summarizes a one-day consultative workshop held on August 8, 2008, in Nairobi, organized by the Kenya Human Rights Commission and the Institute for Security Studies. The event brought together approximately 40 participants from government, security agencies, academia, and civil society to evaluate the role of the African Peer Review Mechanism (APRM) in addressing security governance deficits in Kenya. Key discussions focused on the 2007 general election violence, the role of militia groups like Mungiki, and the reactions of law enforcement agents. The workshop produced several recommendations to strengthen the APRM process, including making questionnaires more incisive, integrating the mechanism into national planning, improving outreach to citizens and the political class, and implementing explicit sanctions for non-compliance instead of 'name-and-shame' tactics.

The document examines the persistence of a 'predatory political and governance culture' in the DRC, tracing it from the colonial era and Mobutu's dictatorship through the 2003–2006 transition. It finds that power-sharing arrangements under the Sun City Agreement effectively removed checks and balances, enabling widespread looting of state assets, mining resources, and public funds. Despite the introduction of new anti-corruption laws and the creation of bodies like the Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission (CELC), these efforts failed due to a lack of political will, institutional dysfunction, and a reliance on donor-driven initiatives without local ownership.

The G8 leaders issued a statement on July 8, 2008, condemning the Zimbabwean authorities for conducting presidential elections amidst systematic violence and intimidation. The leaders refused to recognize the legitimacy of any government not reflecting the will of the people and urged a peaceful resolution through mediation and dialogue. They specifically called for the immediate resumption of humanitarian operations and recommended that the UN Secretary-General appoint a special envoy to monitor the political, human rights, and security situation. The G8 also indicated they would consider financial and other measures against individuals responsible for violence.

The document summarizes a 2008 seminar on the democratic governance of intelligence in South Africa. Key discussions focused on the shift toward human security, the challenge of non-partisanship in post-liberation states, and criticisms regarding the perceived politicization of intelligence services and their failure to anticipate xenophobic violence. The seminar also addressed the contentious nature of the Protection of Information Bill.

The briefing argues that Zimbabwe's political crisis, characterized by contested elections and state power abuse, necessitates a transitional government. Unlike a government of national unity, a transitional government acts as a short-term caretaker to draft a new constitution and create an environment for free and fair elections. The author proposes an inclusive body comprising more than just the MDC and Zanu-PF, potentially with Robert Mugabe remaining as president under strict checks and balances, supported by expanded mediation from SADC, the AU, and the UN, as well as international civilian peacekeepers.

The briefing argues that Zimbabwe's political crisis and the contested re-election of Robert Mugabe in June 2008 necessitate a transitional government rather than a government of national unity. It defines a transitional government as a short-term caretaker authority tasked with drafting a new constitution and preparing for legitimate elections. The author proposes a one-year mandate for an inclusive body comprising more than just the MDC and Zanu-PF, supported by expanded mediation from SADC, the AU, and the UN, as well as international civilian peacekeepers.

The document examines the transition of Zambia's copper industry from state control under Zambia Consolidated Copper Mines Limited (ZCCM) to private ownership. It argues that while privatisation increased production and corporate profits, it led to a decline in social services, poor labour conditions, and environmental degradation. The author highlights a 'resource curse' where the state's failure to negotiate fair development agreements and its tendency to protect foreign investors have left local communities with minimal benefits and increased insecurity.