Summary
The report contends that current global responses to climate change are insufficient to manage the associated security risks, as they often ignore the 'long tail' of extreme outcomes and the potential for abrupt tipping points. It proposes a three-tier 'ABC' framework: aiming to stay below 2C of warming, budgeting for resilience to 3-4C, and contingency planning for 5-7C. The authors advocate for ten key recommendations, including increased investment in transformational RD&D, independent risk assessments, and systematic monitoring of climate tipping points, to prevent catastrophic security failures.
Key insights
- Current international climate agreements, specifically the Cancun Agreements, are insufficient to prevent severe security risks; while they aim for a 2C limit, registered pledges are more consistent with a 3-4C rise, which increases the probability of breaching climate tipping points.
- Climate change is characterized by a 'long tail' in probability distributions, meaning severe, high-impact outcomes are more likely than benign ones, and current models may systematically underestimate the rate of change for elements like Arctic sea ice melt and sea level rise.
- To manage the risk of policy failure or high climate sensitivity, the report recommends that major economies increase public clean energy research, development and demonstration (RD&D) spending by five times by 2020.
- There is an urgent need for a comprehensive, long-lived monitoring system for climate tipping points, as current academic funding systems are insufficient to provide the necessary coordination and early warning for dangerous scenarios.
- Climate change acts as a 'threat multiplier' that can destabilize fragile states by exacerbating resource scarcity, particularly regarding food and water, which may lead to intra- or interstate conflict and mass migration.
- The report identifies 'crash mitigation' planning as a necessary contingency for worst-case scenarios, including options like geoengineering, rapid diffusion of nuclear technology, or large-scale carbon capture and storage.
- Adaptation strategies must account for 'perfect storms'—the interaction of multiple climate and socioeconomic shocks—and avoid 'hard' engineering responses that might inadvertently increase conflict over scarce resources.
- The report argues that the 'stationarity' assumption—that the future climate will stay within the range of past extremes—is no longer valid, meaning all critical infrastructure is potentially vulnerable without adaptive measures.
- Effective risk management requires the separation of policy development from assessment to avoid bias, suggesting that countries establish independent bodies to audit progress toward climate goals.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Mabey, N., Gulledge, J., Finel, B., & Silverthorne, K. (2011). Degrees of Risk. E3G. https://www.e3g.org/wp-content/uploads/E3G_Degrees_of_Risk_Defining_a_Risk_Management_Framework_for_Climate_Security_Full_Report.pdf
- Chicago
- Mabey, Nick, Jay Gulledge, Bernard Finel, and Katherine Silverthorne. Degrees of Risk. E3G, 2011. https://www.e3g.org/wp-content/uploads/E3G_Degrees_of_Risk_Defining_a_Risk_Management_Framework_for_Climate_Security_Full_Report.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Mabey |first1=Nick |last2=Gulledge |first2=Jay |last3=Finel |first3=Bernard |last4=Silverthorne |first4=Katherine |title=Degrees of Risk |publisher=E3G |date=February 2011 |url=https://www.e3g.org/wp-content/uploads/E3G_Degrees_of_Risk_Defining_a_Risk_Management_Framework_for_Climate_Security_Full_Report.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document e3g-001078)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{mabey2011degrees, author = {Mabey, Nick and Gulledge, Jay and Finel, Bernard and Silverthorne, Katherine}, title = {{Degrees of Risk}}, institution = {E3G}, year = {2011}, month = feb, url = {https://www.e3g.org/wp-content/uploads/E3G_Degrees_of_Risk_Defining_a_Risk_Management_Framework_for_Climate_Security_Full_Report.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document e3g-001078} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated