Review, Lessons Learned & Proposals to Reduce Transaction Costs
Summary
The REIPPPP is a highly successful competitive tender process that has attracted significant private investment and sharply reduced renewable energy tariffs in South Africa. Its primary success stems from a combination of strong political support, bankable standardized contracts, and a multi-round auction design that stimulated competition.
Key insights
- The REIPPPP has achieved more investment via Independent Power Producers (IPPs) in four years than in the rest of Sub-Saharan Africa over the past two decades, procuring 6,328 MW amounting to R193bn (USD 20.5bn) across four bid windows.
- Bid tariffs for renewable energy have fallen sharply over the course of the programme; solar PV and wind energy are now cheaper than the national utility Eskom's average cost of supply and the cost of new coal power stations.
- The programme's success is attributed to eight key elements: an enabling policy environment, mandated leadership, adequate resources for transaction advisors, auction design based on international best practice, bankable documentation, fairness and transparency, adequate capital markets, and the maintenance of programme credibility.
- Competitive tenders are found to be more effective than feed-in tariffs (FITs) or directly negotiated projects because they provide a mechanism for real price discovery and are more responsive to market innovations.
- The use of a series of rolling bid windows stimulated competition and allowed for the iterative refinement of RFP documentation and contracts, which reduced transaction costs over time.
- The programme's stringent qualification requirements, including the need for locked-in finance and permits by bid submission, ensured a zero percent failure rate for projects to date.
- Economic development (ED) criteria account for 30% of the final project score, focusing on job creation, local content, ownership, management control, preferential procurement, and socio-economic development.
- The Small Projects IPP Procurement Programme (SP-IPPPP) was designed to encourage SME participation through a two-stage process and lower capacity requirements (1-5 MW), but it has struggled with high transaction costs that remain a deterrent for small players.
- Local commercial banks have dominated debt provision, with the five largest local banks contributing 68% of the external debt to REIPPPP projects.
- Transaction costs are primarily driven by tender design; reducing the burden on bidders through simplified documentation and the 'Returning Compliant Bidder' concept can stimulate competition and lower tariffs.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Eberhard, A., & Naude, R. (n.d.). Review, Lessons Learned & Proposals to Reduce Transaction Costs. JUST SA. https://www.justsaportal.org.za/uploads/files/EberhardNaude_REIPPPPReview_2017_1_1.pdf
- Chicago
- Eberhard, Anton, and Raine Naude. Review, Lessons Learned & Proposals to Reduce Transaction Costs. JUST SA, n.d. https://www.justsaportal.org.za/uploads/files/EberhardNaude_REIPPPPReview_2017_1_1.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Eberhard |first1=Anton |last2=Naude |first2=Raine |title=Review, Lessons Learned & Proposals to Reduce Transaction Costs |publisher=JUST SA |url=https://www.justsaportal.org.za/uploads/files/EberhardNaude_REIPPPPReview_2017_1_1.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document justsa-000011)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{eberhardndreview, author = {Eberhard, Anton and Naude, Raine}, title = {{Review, Lessons Learned \& Proposals to Reduce Transaction Costs}}, institution = {JUST SA}, url = {https://www.justsaportal.org.za/uploads/files/EberhardNaude_REIPPPPReview_2017_1_1.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document justsa-000011} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated