COMMENTS ON: ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORTS FOR KARPOWERSHIP (PTY) LTDs PROPOSED GAS TO POWERSHIP PROJECT AT THE PORTS OF SALDANHA BAY (WESTERN CAPE), PORT OF NGQURA (EASTERN CAPE) AND RICHARDS BAY (KWAZULU NATAL)
Summary
groundWork opposes the Karpowership gas-to-power projects in South Africa, asserting that they lock the country into expensive fossil fuel infrastructure and fail to adequately assess climate and air quality impacts.
Key insights
- The Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs) fail to consider alternative energy technologies, such as renewables, and present the gas project as a foregone conclusion, violating the legal requirement to address alternatives in type, design, and technology.
- The projects risk locking South Africa into a 20-year contract for expensive gas power, which would crowd out cheaper renewable energy and exacerbate the climate crisis.
- The Climate Change Impact Assessments (CCIAs) are inadequate because they omit upstream emissions from gas production, transport, and liquefaction, and use outdated methane Global Warming Potential figures from 2007 instead of the 2013 IPCC report.
- Air quality assessments are flawed as they do not quantify carcinogenic air toxics like formaldehyde and acetaldehyde, nor do they evaluate the cumulative impacts of emissions from other industrial activities in the host ports.
- The projects pose significant safety risks, as LNG carriers and Floating Storage Regasification Units are described as 'floating bombs' that could explode in busy port areas, a scenario not adequately considered in the EIAs.
- Public participation was insufficient, specifically excluding tribal authorities and communities of Dube and Mkhwanazi, as well as subsistence fishers and market gardeners in the affected areas.
- The socio-economic benefits are overstated, as Karpowerships received an exemption from local content requirements and many long-term high-skilled positions are likely to be filled by Turkish crew.
Cite the original document
- APA
- groundWork (2021). COMMENTS ON: ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORTS FOR KARPOWERSHIP (PTY) LTDs PROPOSED GAS TO POWERSHIP PROJECT AT THE PORTS OF SALDANHA BAY (WESTERN CAPE), PORT OF NGQURA (EASTERN CAPE) AND RICHARDS BAY (KWAZULU NATAL). https://groundwork.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/gW-KPs-Triplo4-comments-2021_03_31.pdf
- Chicago
- groundWork. COMMENTS ON: ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORTS FOR KARPOWERSHIP (PTY) LTDs PROPOSED GAS TO POWERSHIP PROJECT AT THE PORTS OF SALDANHA BAY (WESTERN CAPE), PORT OF NGQURA (EASTERN CAPE) AND RICHARDS BAY (KWAZULU NATAL). 2021. https://groundwork.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/gW-KPs-Triplo4-comments-2021_03_31.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite press release |author=groundWork |title=COMMENTS ON: ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORTS FOR KARPOWERSHIP (PTY) LTDs PROPOSED GAS TO POWERSHIP PROJECT AT THE PORTS OF SALDANHA BAY (WESTERN CAPE), PORT OF NGQURA (EASTERN CAPE) AND RICHARDS BAY (KWAZULU NATAL) |date=31 March 2021 |url=https://groundwork.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/gW-KPs-Triplo4-comments-2021_03_31.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document gwza-000106)}}
- BibTeX
- @misc{groundwork2021comments, author = {{groundWork}}, title = {{COMMENTS ON: ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORTS FOR KARPOWERSHIP (PTY) LTDs PROPOSED GAS TO POWERSHIP PROJECT AT THE PORTS OF SALDANHA BAY (WESTERN CAPE), PORT OF NGQURA (EASTERN CAPE) AND RICHARDS BAY (KWAZULU NATAL)}}, publisher = {groundWork}, year = {2021}, month = mar, url = {https://groundwork.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/gW-KPs-Triplo4-comments-2021_03_31.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document gwza-000106} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated