Geoengineering: Assessing Risks in the Era of Planetary Security
Summary
The document argues that the world has entered an era of 'planetary security' as global warming breaches the 1.5°C threshold, leading to increased interest in geoengineering. It defines planetary security as the 'resilient coexistence of human, technological, and ecological systems within the Earth’s biophysical limits.' The author warns that geoengineering is often framed as a necessary emergency remedy but introduces severe risks. Individual methods may fail, cause biophysical harm, or exacerbate international tensions. Collectively, these technologies pose global catastrophic risks, including 'termination shock' (rapid temperature spikes if SRM is stopped), 'systemic destabilization' of ecosystems, and 'overshoot risks' where reliance on these tools delays essential emissions reductions. The paper details various CDR methods (land-based, ocean-based, and engineered) and SRM methods (surface, atmosphere, and space-based), highlighting their energy intensity, potential to disrupt food and water security, and the lack of a global governance framework.
Key insights
- The author introduces the concept of 'planetary security,' which expands beyond human-centric international security to include the integration of human civilizations with the biosphere and the technosphere. It is defined as the "resilient coexistence of human, technological, and ecological systems within the Earth’s biophysical limits."
- Geoengineering is categorized into two primary approaches: carbon dioxide removal (CDR), which extracts CO2 from the atmosphere or ocean, and solar radiation management (SRM), which aims to "artificially cool the planet."
- Individual geoengineering methods carry three distinct risks: they may not work (doing little to stop climate change or even increasing temperatures), they may cause harm by destabilizing "already-fragile biophysical and social systems," or they may exacerbate international tensions due to the absence of an international governance framework.
- Collectively, geoengineering poses three forms of global catastrophic risk: 'termination shock' (rapid temperature increases if SRM is suddenly stopped), 'systemic destabilization' (cascading failures leading to nonlinear ecosystem changes), and 'overshoot risks' (irreversible changes caused by delaying emissions reductions).
- Current CDR capacity is minimal, at approximately 2.2 billion metric tons (GtCO2) per year, primarily through afforestation. Novel engineered methods like direct air capture (DAC) contribute very little, approximately 0.000004 GtCO2 per year, and are criticized as being "unproven at scale."
- Stratospheric aerosol injection (SAI) is highlighted as a high-risk SRM method that could disrupt major weather patterns in Africa and Asia, including the monsoon, and potentially lead to "termination shock."
- The document warns that the 'net zero' accounting system is being used as a 'paper tiger' to allow continued fossil fuel dependence, as some countries rely heavily on carbon removal without caps or coordinated oversight.
- Large-scale deployment of certain CDR methods could severely threaten global food and water security. For example, achieving full technical mitigation potential for BECCS and afforestation could require land "three times the area of the United States" and push over 300 million people into food insecurity.
- The European Union has adopted a mixed approach to geoengineering, implementing a Carbon Removals and Carbon Farming (CRCF) certification framework while maintaining a "precautionary stance toward SRM."
- The author argues that geoengineering is often presented through a 'risk-risk' framework—a binary choice between climate breakdown and technological intervention—which ignores the possibility of pursuing security responses that benefit the many rather than the few.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Dyke, O. L. M. B. J. (2025). Geoengineering: Assessing Risks in the Era of Planetary Security. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. https://carnegieendowment.org/europe/research/2025/07/geoengineering-assessing-risks-in-the-era-of-planetary-security
- Chicago
- Dyke, Olivia Lazard, Mandi Bissett, James. Geoengineering: Assessing Risks in the Era of Planetary Security. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 2025. https://carnegieendowment.org/europe/research/2025/07/geoengineering-assessing-risks-in-the-era-of-planetary-security.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Dyke |first1=Olivia Lazard, Mandi Bissett, James |title=Geoengineering: Assessing Risks in the Era of Planetary Security |publisher=Carnegie Endowment for International Peace |date=16 July 2025 |url=https://carnegieendowment.org/europe/research/2025/07/geoengineering-assessing-risks-in-the-era-of-planetary-security |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document carnend-001765)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{dyke2025geoengineering, author = {Dyke, Olivia Lazard, Mandi Bissett, James}, title = {{Geoengineering: Assessing Risks in the Era of Planetary Security}}, institution = {Carnegie Endowment for International Peace}, year = {2025}, month = jul, url = {https://carnegieendowment.org/europe/research/2025/07/geoengineering-assessing-risks-in-the-era-of-planetary-security}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document carnend-001765} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated