The Implications of New Approaches to Industrial Policy for Economic Growth and Industrial Development: A Multi-Country Comparative Study with Lessons for South Africa and Africa
Summary
The document analyzes the resurgence of 'new industrial policy'—shifting from traditional protectionism to sophisticated state-market coordination—across advanced, emerging, and resource-rich economies. By comparing models from East Asia, Europe, North America, and the Middle East, it argues that successful industrial transformation requires a proactive state that coordinates finance, technology, and skills while disciplining firm performance. For Africa, the author advocates for leveraging the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA) to build regional value chains and transitioning from raw commodity exports to high-value manufacturing through targeted, performance-based interventions.
Key insights
- The 'new industrial policy' differs from traditional models by focusing on building ecosystems of capability—including finance, technology institutions, and innovation systems—rather than relying solely on tariffs and import substitution.
- East Asian economies, specifically Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan, achieved success through disciplined state coordination, strategic export targeting, and the use of 'policy loans' to direct capital toward strategic sectors.
- South Korea's industrial ascent was supported by the nationalisation of its banking system from the 1960s to the 1980s, which allowed the state to direct over 50% of total bank loans as 'policy loans' to strategic sectors.
- China's manufacturing dominance is attributed to a hybrid model of state direction and market mechanisms, including the strategic use of Special Economic Zones (SEZs) and the management of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) for technology transfer.
- The United States employs a 'covert industrial policy,' supporting strategic industries like defence and semiconductors through public procurement, DARPA-funded research, and tax incentives, even while publicly promoting free-market principles.
- Norway avoided 'Dutch Disease' by establishing the Government Pension Fund Global to decouple oil revenues from the domestic economy and by implementing stringent local-content requirements to build a domestic offshore engineering cluster.
- Germany's industrial strength is underpinned by the 'Mittelstand' (SMEs) and a 'Dual System' of vocational training that combines classroom theory with industrial apprenticeships.
- India's transformation is characterized by a 'service-led' model, leapfrogging directly into high-productivity IT services, though the author notes that manufacturing remains essential for large-scale employment.
- Indonesia's 'hilirisasi' (downstreaming) policy, including a 2020 ban on raw nickel ore exports, successfully forced global companies to invest in domestic processing plants, increasing processed nickel output.
- Brazil's EMBRAPA model demonstrates how mission-oriented public research can transform unproductive ecosystems (like the Cerrado savannah) into highly productive agricultural zones.
- Iran's industrialization shows that technological self-reliance can be built even under severe sanctions, though it warns against 'wrong diversification' into low-complexity, rent-based industries.
- South Africa's industrial history is marked by the 'Minerals-Energy Complex' and a subsequent period of 'secular deindustrialisation' following rapid trade liberalisation in the 1990s.
- The author argues that Africa must move from being a supplier of raw materials to a producer of higher-value goods by using the AfCFTA to build regional value chains (RVCs) and harmonizing standards and regulations.
- Effective industrial policy in Africa requires 'export discipline,' where state support is conditional and linked to measurable productivity and export targets to prevent rent-seeking.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Mudungwe, N. (2026). The Implications of New Approaches to Industrial Policy for Economic Growth and Industrial Development: A Multi-Country Comparative Study with Lessons for South Africa and Africa. Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies. https://forum.tips.org.za/images/forum%20papers/2026/Paper_Nicholas_Mudungwe__The_Implications_of_New_Approaches_to_Industrial_Policy_for_Economic_Growth_and_Industrial_Development_A_Multi-Country_Comparative_Study_with_Lessons_for_South_Africa_and_Africa.pdf
- Chicago
- Mudungwe, Nicholas. The Implications of New Approaches to Industrial Policy for Economic Growth and Industrial Development: A Multi-Country Comparative Study with Lessons for South Africa and Africa. Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies, 2026. https://forum.tips.org.za/images/forum%20papers/2026/Paper_Nicholas_Mudungwe__The_Implications_of_New_Approaches_to_Industrial_Policy_for_Economic_Growth_and_Industrial_Development_A_Multi-Country_Comparative_Study_with_Lessons_for_South_Africa_and_Africa.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Mudungwe |first1=Nicholas |title=The Implications of New Approaches to Industrial Policy for Economic Growth and Industrial Development: A Multi-Country Comparative Study with Lessons for South Africa and Africa |publisher=Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies |date=4 August 2026 |url=https://forum.tips.org.za/images/forum%20papers/2026/Paper_Nicholas_Mudungwe__The_Implications_of_New_Approaches_to_Industrial_Policy_for_Economic_Growth_and_Industrial_Development_A_Multi-Country_Comparative_Study_with_Lessons_for_South_Africa_and_Africa.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document tipsza-000345)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{mudungwe2026implications, author = {Mudungwe, Nicholas}, title = {{The Implications of New Approaches to Industrial Policy for Economic Growth and Industrial Development: A Multi-Country Comparative Study with Lessons for South Africa and Africa}}, institution = {Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies}, year = {2026}, month = aug, url = {https://forum.tips.org.za/images/forum%20papers/2026/Paper_Nicholas_Mudungwe__The_Implications_of_New_Approaches_to_Industrial_Policy_for_Economic_Growth_and_Industrial_Development_A_Multi-Country_Comparative_Study_with_Lessons_for_South_Africa_and_Africa.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document tipsza-000345} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated