WRONG SIDE OF THE TRACKS
Summary
This report concludes that bitumen-by-rail is a niche market unable to replace pipeline capacity due to high logistical costs, market volatility, and infrastructure constraints. It finds that rail shipments to the U.S. Gulf Coast in early 2014 represented only 5.7 percent of the proposed Keystone XL pipeline's capacity.
Key insights
- Bitumen-by-rail is unable to replace proposed pipeline capacity in the foreseeable future; total rail imports into the U.S. account for approximately 3 percent of the total additional capacity required for future Canadian crude oil production growth.
- The current loading capacity for tar sands bitumen is 240,000 barrels per day (bpd), and while planned expansions could reach 800,000 bpd by 2016, utilization has rarely exceeded 50 percent. This is far below the 4 million bpd of additional capacity estimated by the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers (CAPP) as necessary for growth to 2030.
- Large-scale producers cannot currently avoid the 'diluent penalty' (the cost of expensive diluent) because unit train terminals require feeder pipelines, which only transport diluted bitumen (dilbit). The 'optimum configuration' of shipping undiluted bitumen by unit train, cited by the U.S. State Department as cost-competitive with pipelines, has not been achieved at scale.
- Shipping tar sands bitumen by rail to the U.S. Gulf Coast has been largely unprofitable throughout 2014 due to narrow price differentials between Alberta and the Gulf Coast, meaning there is little incentive for traders to exploit arbitrage.
- Pipeline transport provides higher 'netbacks' (price received minus transport cost) than rail. For example, dilbit delivered by pipeline has a higher netback than raw bitumen delivered via manifest rail, and unit train delivery of rawbit—if achieved—would likely still be lower than pipeline dilbit by approximately $7 per barrel.
- The U.S. West Coast offers better profit prospects due to shorter distances and less domestic crude flooding, but development is severely hindered by local opposition to rail terminals and tanker traffic in Washington and California.
- Rail transport is highly vulnerable to extreme winter weather in the Canadian prairies and the U.S. Midwest, which causes loading delays and track closures, unlike underground pipelines.
- Increased crude-by-rail traffic has caused significant congestion on North American rail networks, leading to delays for other commodities like grain and passenger services such as Amtrak's Empire Builder.
- New safety regulations and the phasing out of DOT-111 tank cars are expected to increase costs for tar sands shippers, particularly through higher leasing costs if speed restrictions increase tank car cycle times.
- There is significant overcapacity at unloading terminals, particularly in the Gulf Coast, meaning that the existence of unloading capacity is not a reliable indicator of actual bitumen movement.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Stockman, L., McKinnon, H., Kretzmann, S., & Makhijani, S. (2014). WRONG SIDE OF THE TRACKS. Oil Change International. https://oilchange.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/OCI-Wrong-Side-of-the-Tracks_Final.pdf
- Chicago
- Stockman, Lorne, Hannah McKinnon, Steve Kretzmann, and Shakuntala Makhijani. WRONG SIDE OF THE TRACKS. Oil Change International, 2014. https://oilchange.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/OCI-Wrong-Side-of-the-Tracks_Final.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Stockman |first1=Lorne |last2=McKinnon |first2=Hannah |last3=Kretzmann |first3=Steve |last4=Makhijani |first4=Shakuntala |title=WRONG SIDE OF THE TRACKS |publisher=Oil Change International |date=September 2014 |url=https://oilchange.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/OCI-Wrong-Side-of-the-Tracks_Final.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document oilcha-000550)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{stockman2014wrong, author = {Stockman, Lorne and McKinnon, Hannah and Kretzmann, Steve and Makhijani, Shakuntala}, title = {{WRONG SIDE OF THE TRACKS}}, institution = {Oil Change International}, year = {2014}, month = sep, url = {https://oilchange.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/OCI-Wrong-Side-of-the-Tracks_Final.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document oilcha-000550} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated