Taking stock of the just transition from coal in South Africa
Summary
The document analyzes the political and socio-economic complexities of South Africa's transition from coal, finding that while the concept of a 'just transition' is mainstreamed, it is often used by different actors to promote diverging economic and political interests.
Key insights
- The concept of just transition in South Africa is used as a political tool to advance vastly different agendas, ranging from transformative socio-economic change to narrow decarbonization that maintains the existing political and economic status quo.
- South Africa faces significant economic and financial barriers to its transition, including a high national debt burden and a funding gap where most international support comes as concessional loans rather than grants, increasing the state's debt.
- The Mpumalanga province is disproportionately affected by the coal transition, with coal mining accounting for 20% of its GDP and 85% of coal employment in 2022, while the region also suffers from high poverty and unemployment rates.
- Institutional challenges include 'state capture' by private interests and a fragmented governance structure where multiple national departments have overlapping mandates, leading to disjointed policy implementation.
- Environmental risks are severe due to at least 400 abandoned coal mines, which cause land pollution and acidic water; rehabilitation is hindered by a lack of transparency in funding and companies using 'care and maintenance' status to avoid closure obligations.
- Trade unions are divided in their approach: some, like COSATU, advocate for a transformative eco-socialist state and restorative justice, while others, like NUM, oppose coal phase-down without guaranteed government support for workers and reject the privatization of the energy sector.
- The Department of Mineral Resources and Energy (DMRE) promotes a narrower 'just energy transition' and advocates for 'clean coal' technologies like CCUS, despite their global commercial uncertainty and the risk of carbon lock-in.
- Eskom is attempting to transform its business model through unbundling and repowering decommissioned plants, as seen in the Komati project, but its efforts are constrained by financial bailouts and operational crises.
- Civil society organizations emphasize a transformative approach that includes marginalized groups and addresses non-energy issues like food security and basic services, while also challenging the narrative of gas as a clean transition fuel.
- There is a significant disconnect between top-down national energy planning and bottom-up local needs, with stakeholder engagement often treated as a formality ('tick box' exercise) rather than a meaningful participatory process.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Strambo, C., Patel, M., & Maimele, S. (2024). Taking stock of the just transition from coal in South Africa. JUST SA. https://www.justsaportal.org.za/uploads/files/just-transition-coal-south-africa.pdf
- Chicago
- Strambo, Claudia, Muhammed Patel, and Seutame Maimele. Taking stock of the just transition from coal in South Africa. JUST SA, 2024. https://www.justsaportal.org.za/uploads/files/just-transition-coal-south-africa.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Strambo |first1=Claudia |last2=Patel |first2=Muhammed |last3=Maimele |first3=Seutame |title=Taking stock of the just transition from coal in South Africa |publisher=JUST SA |date=August 2024 |url=https://www.justsaportal.org.za/uploads/files/just-transition-coal-south-africa.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document justsa-000018)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{strambo2024taking, author = {Strambo, Claudia and Patel, Muhammed and Maimele, Seutame}, title = {{Taking stock of the just transition from coal in South Africa}}, institution = {JUST SA}, year = {2024}, month = aug, url = {https://www.justsaportal.org.za/uploads/files/just-transition-coal-south-africa.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document justsa-000018} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated