Falling Short: Shale Development in West Virginia Fails to Deliver on Economic Promises
Summary
The report finds that shale development in West Virginia has underperformed initial economic projections, with job gains and tax revenues failing to meet targets while creating significant long-term financial liabilities for the state.
Key insights
- Economic development gains from the shale industry have fallen short of initial projections, partly due to exaggerated industry claims and a failure to anticipate the sustained collapse of natural gas prices caused by increased production.
- Natural gas severance tax revenues grew until Fiscal Year 2015 and then declined; by Fiscal Year 2018, these revenues were only 15% higher than in FY 2008 when adjusted for inflation.
- Job growth in the natural gas sector was lower than projected, adding only 2,600 net new jobs from 2008 to 2017 compared to projections of up to 5,700 by 2015. Growth was driven by temporary pipeline construction, while jobs in drilling and support activities actually declined.
- Production is highly concentrated, with six counties (Doddridge, Wetzel, Tyler, Ritchie, Marshall, and Harrison) accounting for 80% of West Virginia's natural gas production in 2017.
- Shale development has created substantial unfunded liabilities for the state in the form of orphaned wells. As of June 2018, the state had an outstanding liability of $205 million for 4,560 orphaned wells, while the dedicated reclamation fund held only $374,986.
- The expansion of inexpensive shale gas contributed substantially to the economic collapse of the coal mining industry in West Virginia, with steam coal production for power generation falling 32% since 2010.
- In the top producing counties, economic indicators like earnings and employment follow a boom-and-bust pattern that tracks the price of natural gas rather than providing sustained growth.
- The shale industry is financially unstable, with many companies spending more on capital expenditures than they realize from selling hydrocarbons. Major Appalachian drillers EQT, Antero, and Southwestern Energy have largely failed to become financially sustainable.
- Claims that Appalachian petrochemical development will provide significant economic benefits are likely overstated due to competition from the Permian basin and global petrochemical expansions in countries like Saudi Arabia, Iran, and Qatar.
- The authors recommend increasing the natural gas severance tax rate from 5% to 10% to fund the West Virginia Future Fund, which could potentially reach $1.1 billion by FY 2023 to support economic diversification.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Kunkel, C., O’Leary, S., & Boettner, T. (2019). Falling Short: Shale Development in West Virginia Fails to Deliver on Economic Promises. Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis. https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/resources/West-Virginia-Shale-Development-Falls-Short_February-2019.pdf
- Chicago
- Kunkel, Cathy, Sean O’Leary, and Ted Boettner. Falling Short: Shale Development in West Virginia Fails to Deliver on Economic Promises. Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis, 2019. https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/resources/West-Virginia-Shale-Development-Falls-Short_February-2019.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Kunkel |first1=Cathy |last2=O’Leary |first2=Sean |last3=Boettner |first3=Ted |title=Falling Short: Shale Development in West Virginia Fails to Deliver on Economic Promises |publisher=Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis |date=February 2019 |url=https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/resources/West-Virginia-Shale-Development-Falls-Short_February-2019.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document ieefa-002079)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{kunkel2019falling, author = {Kunkel, Cathy and O’Leary, Sean and Boettner, Ted}, title = {{Falling Short: Shale Development in West Virginia Fails to Deliver on Economic Promises}}, institution = {Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis}, year = {2019}, month = feb, url = {https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/resources/West-Virginia-Shale-Development-Falls-Short_February-2019.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document ieefa-002079} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated