Engagement and Divestment: Shareholders Transcend a False Binary
Summary
The document contends that the perceived binary choice between engagement and divestment is false, asserting that engagement strategies require the credible threat of divestment to be effective. It highlights that many institutional investors, such as the New York State Common Retirement Fund, have transitioned from engagement-only approaches to divestment after companies failed to meet transition benchmarks. The briefing outlines a 'credible and time-bound escalation' framework and suggests three tests for deciding when to exit an investment: the company's risk profile, the existence of credible pathways for change, and the company's good faith in dialogue.
Key insights
- Engagement and divestment are complementary tools rather than opposing strategies; engagement requires the possibility of divestment to maintain credibility and leverage with corporate management.
- Effective shareholder engagement should follow a principle of 'credible and time-bound escalation,' moving from simple communication to more forceful measures like litigation or divestment if goals are not met.
- Several international standard-setters and alliances support the pairing of engagement with clear exit strategies. Examples include the IAIS, which suggests 'escalation measures' including 'exclusion decisions,' and GFANZ, which highlights AXA's 'three-strikes-and-you’re-out' approach.
- The New York State Common Retirement Fund (CRF) provides a case study of this transition, moving from lobbying ExxonMobil for better climate risk disclosure in 2017 to divesting from the company and its peers in 2024 after determining their responses were 'disappointing' and 'frustrating.'
- Other major institutional investors have adopted similar paths, including New York City’s pension systems, the Church of England pension, and the Dutch pension fund PFZW, often after determining that the fossil fuel sector was not making adequate progress toward net-zero.
- Fiduciary duty justifies divestment when the fossil fuel industry's financial performance is poor; the sector has substantially underperformed the stock market over the last 10 years and its S&P 500 weighting has dropped from nearly 30% in 1980 to the low single digits.
- Investors should use three specific tests to determine when to execute an exit strategy: the company's risk profile (market headwinds), whether credible pathways for fundamental business model change exist, and the company's good faith in engaging with shareholders.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Chung, C., & Cohn, D. (2024). Engagement and Divestment: Shareholders Transcend a False Binary. Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis. https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/2024-09/091124_REVISION_ET_Engage%20Divest%20Briefing%20Note_13841.pdf
- Chicago
- Chung, Connor, and Dan Cohn. Engagement and Divestment: Shareholders Transcend a False Binary. Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis, 2024. https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/2024-09/091124_REVISION_ET_Engage%20Divest%20Briefing%20Note_13841.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Chung |first1=Connor |last2=Cohn |first2=Dan |title=Engagement and Divestment: Shareholders Transcend a False Binary |publisher=Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis |date=September 2024 |url=https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/2024-09/091124_REVISION_ET_Engage%20Divest%20Briefing%20Note_13841.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document ieefa-000889)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{chung2024engagement, author = {Chung, Connor and Cohn, Dan}, title = {{Engagement and Divestment: Shareholders Transcend a False Binary}}, institution = {Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis}, year = {2024}, month = sep, url = {https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/2024-09/091124_REVISION_ET_Engage%20Divest%20Briefing%20Note_13841.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document ieefa-000889} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated