CO2-Preis in Deutschland Umsetzung des ETS II und des Klima-Sozialfonds in Deutschland
Summary
The report analyzes the transition of Germany's nEHS to the EU's ETS II starting in 2027, warning of potential certificate scarcity and sharp CO2 price increases. It recommends a national minimum price and an 'opt-in' for sectors not covered by ETS II to maintain climate ambition. To mitigate social hardship, the authors advocate for the rapid introduction of a 'Klimageld' (climate money) and targeted investment programs for vulnerable households, noting that the EU's Social Climate Fund alone is insufficient for Germany's needs.
Key insights
- The transition to ETS II is likely to cause significant certificate scarcity and high CO2 prices because the planned annual cap reduction is over five times stronger than historical reduction rates, while member state projections for emissions remain significantly above the cap.
- The authors recommend that Germany use the 'opt-in' option to include sectors currently covered by the nEHS but not planned for ETS II, ensuring that existing CO2 price signals are not lost.
- To avoid price shocks and increase predictability, the report suggests raising the national CO2 price path before the ETS II launch and implementing a national minimum price, potentially oriented toward climate damage costs of approximately 240 Euro by 2030.
- Estimated revenues for Germany from ETS II auctions between 2027 and 2032 vary wildly based on the CO2 price: approximately 48.5 billion Euro at 50 Euro/t CO2, 111.4 billion Euro at 100 Euro/t CO2, and 237.3 billion Euro at 200 Euro/t CO2.
- The Social Climate Fund (SCF) provides Germany with a maximum of 5.3 billion Euro for 2026-2032, which is deemed insufficient to cover the needs of vulnerable groups; therefore, additional national auction revenues should be used.
- A 'Klimageld' (per-capita payment) is legally feasible under ETS II, but financing it through the SCF is restricted to temporary support for vulnerable groups (max 37.5% of funds). Financing via general national auction revenues is more flexible but requires clarification from the EU Commission regarding 'climate dividends' or 'social measures'.
- Using a combined indicator of high energy cost burden, poor building efficiency, and low income, the report identifies 3.1 million households in Germany as vulnerable regarding heating energy needs as of 2022.
- A per-capita Klimageld alone cannot prevent a 'lock-in' of vulnerable households in fossil energy use; it must be accompanied by targeted investment measures such as window replacements, cellar ceiling insulation, and social public transport tickets.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Fiedler, S., Peiseler, F., Maier, M., Meemken, S., Zahn, P., Cludius, J., Graichen, J., Schumacher, K., & Healy, S. (2024). CO2-Preis in Deutschland Umsetzung des ETS II und des Klima-Sozialfonds in Deutschland. Germanwatch. https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/202402_ets2_klimasozialfonds.pdf
- Chicago
- Fiedler, Swantje, Florian Peiseler, Michael Maier, Simon Meemken, Paulin Zahn, Johanna Cludius, Jakob Graichen, Katja Schumacher, and Sienna Healy. CO2-Preis in Deutschland Umsetzung des ETS II und des Klima-Sozialfonds in Deutschland. Germanwatch, 2024. https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/202402_ets2_klimasozialfonds.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Fiedler |first1=Swantje |last2=Peiseler |first2=Florian |last3=Maier |first3=Michael |last4=Meemken |first4=Simon |last5=Zahn |first5=Paulin |last6=Cludius |first6=Johanna |last7=Graichen |first7=Jakob |last8=Schumacher |first8=Katja |last9=Healy |first9=Sienna |title=CO2-Preis in Deutschland Umsetzung des ETS II und des Klima-Sozialfonds in Deutschland |publisher=Germanwatch |date=February 2024 |url=https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/202402_ets2_klimasozialfonds.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document gerwat-001003)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{fiedler2024co2preis, author = {Fiedler, Swantje and Peiseler, Florian and Maier, Michael and Meemken, Simon and Zahn, Paulin and Cludius, Johanna and Graichen, Jakob and Schumacher, Katja and Healy, Sienna}, title = {{CO2-Preis in Deutschland Umsetzung des ETS II und des Klima-Sozialfonds in Deutschland}}, institution = {Germanwatch}, year = {2024}, month = feb, url = {https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/202402_ets2_klimasozialfonds.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document gerwat-001003} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated