KEY POLITICAL ECONOMY AND ENTANGLEMENT ISSUES OF THE LOW-CARBON TRANSITION IN G20 COUNTRIES
Summary
The document examines the political economy of the low-carbon transition, highlighting how 'high carbon entanglement'—including fiscal dependencies, incumbent industry power, and infrastructure path dependency—can obstruct climate goals. It argues that traditional techno-economic models fail to predict disruptive market shifts, such as the restructuring of European utilities. Through case studies on Vattenfall's lignite asset sale, 2050 pathway planning in South Africa, the UK, and Germany, and the failure of Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) in Europe, the report demonstrates that vested interests often block transition pathways. It recommends a 'mixed economy' approach where the state actively reforms institutions and manages stranded assets and social liabilities to ensure an orderly transition.
Key insights
- Traditional techno-economic and macroeconomic modeling is insufficient for managing low-carbon transitions because it focuses on marginal shifts and fails to account for institutional structures, investment dynamics, and the influence of vested interests.
- The transition to low-carbon energy is characterized by high complexity, including vertical and horizontal dependencies, high capital intensity, and strong path dependency, which creates significant inertia in existing energy systems.
- Relying exclusively on carbon pricing is an ineffective strategy for rapid transformation because it ignores market failures, legacy infrastructure, and the political economy of national and sectoral conditions.
- Fiscal entanglement poses a significant risk to governments, as the transition reduces revenue from fossil fuel royalties and taxes; for example, in Russia and Saudi Arabia, fossil fuel income accounts for over two-thirds of government revenue.
- The sale of Vattenfall's lignite assets to EPH illustrates how short-term political interests and union pressure in Germany prevented a managed, socially responsible phase-out of coal, potentially leaving the public sector liable for land reclamation costs.
- Long-term 2050 planning can be undermined if it lacks transparency or fails to incorporate the costs of inaction; in South Africa, a lack of transparency in the LTMS process damaged stakeholder relationships and led to industry backlash.
- The UK's experience with the Climate Change Act shows that independent oversight bodies, such as the Committee on Climate Change (CCC), are essential for maintaining scientific integrity and ensuring government accountability regardless of political shifts.
- The failure of Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) in Europe was driven by the assumption that utilities would lead deployment, whereas utilities actually viewed CCS as a threat to their existing unabated coal assets and business models.
- To achieve deep decarbonization, governments must adopt a 'mixed economy' approach, acting as strategic interveners to reform institutions and provide public-interest infrastructure, such as CO2 transport and storage networks.
Cite the original document
- APA
- MABEY, N., WEBB, M., SCHWARTZKOPFF, J., BORN, C., & LITTLECOTT, C. (2017). KEY POLITICAL ECONOMY AND ENTANGLEMENT ISSUES OF THE LOW-CARBON TRANSITION IN G20 COUNTRIES. E3G. https://www.e3g.org/wp-content/uploads/docs/E3G_Political_Economy_Entanglement_input_to_OECD_G20_report_May_2017.pdf
- Chicago
- MABEY, NICK, MATTHEW WEBB, JULIAN SCHWARTZKOPFF, CAMILLA BORN, and CHRIS LITTLECOTT. KEY POLITICAL ECONOMY AND ENTANGLEMENT ISSUES OF THE LOW-CARBON TRANSITION IN G20 COUNTRIES. E3G, 2017. https://www.e3g.org/wp-content/uploads/docs/E3G_Political_Economy_Entanglement_input_to_OECD_G20_report_May_2017.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=MABEY |first1=NICK |last2=WEBB |first2=MATTHEW |last3=SCHWARTZKOPFF |first3=JULIAN |last4=BORN |first4=CAMILLA |last5=LITTLECOTT |first5=CHRIS |title=KEY POLITICAL ECONOMY AND ENTANGLEMENT ISSUES OF THE LOW-CARBON TRANSITION IN G20 COUNTRIES |publisher=E3G |date=February 2017 |url=https://www.e3g.org/wp-content/uploads/docs/E3G_Political_Economy_Entanglement_input_to_OECD_G20_report_May_2017.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document e3g-001129)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{mabey2017key, author = {MABEY, NICK and WEBB, MATTHEW and SCHWARTZKOPFF, JULIAN and BORN, CAMILLA and LITTLECOTT, CHRIS}, title = {{KEY POLITICAL ECONOMY AND ENTANGLEMENT ISSUES OF THE LOW-CARBON TRANSITION IN G20 COUNTRIES}}, institution = {E3G}, year = {2017}, month = feb, url = {https://www.e3g.org/wp-content/uploads/docs/E3G_Political_Economy_Entanglement_input_to_OECD_G20_report_May_2017.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document e3g-001129} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated