Феномен «ресурсного проклятия»: Казахстан, Мексика и Индонезия
Summary
The report examines how Kazakhstan, Mexico, and Indonesia have navigated the 'resource curse.' Kazakhstan struggles with high energy dependence, corruption, and a bloated quasi-state sector despite efforts to diversify via infrastructure and education. Mexico has successfully diversified its exports through trade agreements like NAFTA but suffers from an 'institutional Dutch disease' where the state budget remains heavily dependent on oil, contributing to weak tax collection and systemic insecurity. Indonesia transitioned from oil dependence to a reliance on 'soft commodities' like palm oil and internal consumption, though it faces challenges with labor productivity, logistics, and market cartels.
Key insights
- Kazakhstan's economy is heavily dependent on energy exports, with hydrocarbons rising from 15% of total exports in 1992 to 75% by 1998. While the National Fund was created in 2001 as a 'fund for future generations,' it has since become a primary source of budget funding, especially after 2008.
- Kazakhstan faces a significant imbalance between oil production and refining capacity; the country produces 70–80 million tons of oil annually but refines only about 15 million tons, necessitating the import of 30% of its light petroleum products.
- The 'quasi-state sector' in Kazakhstan, fueled by high oil revenues, has led to the creation of inefficient state enterprises. An example is the 'Astana Solar' plant, which produced solar panels eight times more expensive than Chinese imports.
- Mexico has largely avoided the resource curse in its export sector by transitioning from import substitution to a neoliberal open-market model in 1986 and joining NAFTA in 1994. Oil now accounts for only about 5% of export revenues, while the economy is driven by industrial exports like automobiles and electronics.
- Despite diversified exports, Mexico suffers from an 'institutional Dutch disease' where the government budget remains highly dependent on oil. This reduces the state's incentive to expand its tax base, resulting in one of the lowest tax-to-GDP ratios in the OECD (17.4% of GDP in 2015).
- Systemic insecurity and the power of drug cartels in Mexico act as a 'ransom' or informal tax on businesses, which some experts link to the state's weakness in formal tax collection due to easy oil rents.
- Indonesia successfully reduced its oil dependence after the 1970s by investing oil rents into agriculture, education, and infrastructure under the Suharto administration. By the 2000s, oil rent as a percentage of GDP fell to below 3%.
- Indonesia has shifted its resource dependence from oil to 'soft commodities' such as palm oil and rubber. While this is more labor-intensive than oil extraction, the budget remains vulnerable to the volatility of these commodity prices.
- Modern Indonesia's economic growth is driven by a young population (median age 28) and strong internal consumption, though it is hindered by poor logistics and low labor productivity compared to regional competitors like Vietnam and Malaysia.
- The Indonesian market is characterized by the prevalence of cartels, particularly in the palm oil and sugar sectors, which limit competition and create barriers for new market entrants.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Мовчан, А., Спивак, В., Зотин, А., & Григорьев, В. (2017). Феномен «ресурсного проклятия»: Казахстан, Мексика и Индонезия. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. https://carnegieendowment.org/ru/russia-eurasia/posts/2017/10/fenomen-resursnogo-proklyatiya-kazahstan-meksika-i-indoneziya
- Chicago
- Мовчан, Андрей, Вита Спивак, Александр Зотин, and Владимир Григорьев. Феномен «ресурсного проклятия»: Казахстан, Мексика и Индонезия. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 2017. https://carnegieendowment.org/ru/russia-eurasia/posts/2017/10/fenomen-resursnogo-proklyatiya-kazahstan-meksika-i-indoneziya.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Мовчан |first1=Андрей |last2=Спивак |first2=Вита |last3=Зотин |first3=Александр |last4=Григорьев |first4=Владимир |title=Феномен «ресурсного проклятия»: Казахстан, Мексика и Индонезия |publisher=Carnegie Endowment for International Peace |date=27 October 2017 |url=https://carnegieendowment.org/ru/russia-eurasia/posts/2017/10/fenomen-resursnogo-proklyatiya-kazahstan-meksika-i-indoneziya |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document carnend-002321)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{2017, author = {Мовчан, Андрей and Спивак, Вита and Зотин, Александр and Григорьев, Владимир}, title = {{Феномен «ресурсного проклятия»: Казахстан, Мексика и Индонезия}}, institution = {Carnegie Endowment for International Peace}, year = {2017}, month = oct, url = {https://carnegieendowment.org/ru/russia-eurasia/posts/2017/10/fenomen-resursnogo-proklyatiya-kazahstan-meksika-i-indoneziya}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document carnend-002321} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated