Enam Kunci untuk Mewujudkan Nilai Tambah yang Berkeadilan dalam Pertambangan
Summary
The briefing outlines six keys for achieving equitable value addition in mining: establishing clear strategies based on economic feasibility and market prospects; adhering to 'do no harm' environmental and social principles; designing tailored policy mechanisms; mitigating corruption risks; securing appropriate international financial and technical support; and ensuring transparency and community engagement. It warns that pursuing value addition for political gain rather than socio-economic benefit can lead to ineffective policies and negative outcomes.
Key insights
- Governments must base value-addition strategies on specific strategic goals for each mineral and value chain stage, informed by economic feasibility, market prospects, and cost-benefit analyses. The document notes that the potential for government revenue varies significantly by mineral; for example, nickel processing in Indonesia can add 60 percent value to taxed products, whereas processing copper into cathodes may only add 4-6 percent.
- Economic competitiveness in mineral processing is driven by several factors, including the scale of mineral supply, transport costs, and access to reliable, competitively priced clean energy. The document highlights that Indonesia's large nickel reserves forced Chinese companies to build smelters domestically, whereas its smaller bauxite reserves made similar export bans less effective.
- Value-addition strategies face significant risks from technological shifts that can alter market demand. For instance, while copper and steel demand is expected to remain strong, the battery value chain is volatile; LFP batteries are predicted to dominate in the next decade, followed by sodium-ion batteries, potentially rendering current NMC battery investments obsolete.
- The 'do no harm' principle is essential to prevent severe environmental and social damage, such as deforestation and toxic waste. The document suggests that development partners should provide conservation financing to incentivize governments to establish 'no-go zones' in environmentally sensitive areas, as short-term pressure for jobs and revenue often leads governments to ignore environmental risks.
- Governments use various policy instruments to drive value addition, including restrictions (export bans), incentives (tax holidays, subsidies), and drivers (infrastructure investment). However, the document warns that these can be counterproductive if they divert public funds from other development priorities or if they are used to benefit specific individuals through corruption.
- Value-addition policies are highly susceptible to corruption across several stages: policy-making, licensing, financial incentives, infrastructure construction, and environmental assessments. For example, the licensing of nickel smelters in Indonesia has been accused of involving nepotism and bribery.
- International support from consumer countries and development partners is necessary but can be contradictory. While initiatives like the Mineral Security Partnership (MSP) aim to support local value addition, other policies—such as the US Inflation Reduction Act's tax credits or the EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism—may inadvertently hinder investment in low-income producing countries that lack free trade agreements or the means to reduce emissions.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Olan'g, T. S. M. S. S. (2024). Enam Kunci untuk Mewujudkan Nilai Tambah yang Berkeadilan dalam Pertambangan. Natural Resource Governance Institute. https://resourcegovernance.org/id/publications/enam-kunci-untuk-mewujudkan-nilai-tambah-yang-berkeadilan-dalam-pertambangan
- Chicago
- Olan'g, Thomas Scurfield, Matthieu Salomon, Silas. Enam Kunci untuk Mewujudkan Nilai Tambah yang Berkeadilan dalam Pertambangan. Natural Resource Governance Institute, 2024. https://resourcegovernance.org/id/publications/enam-kunci-untuk-mewujudkan-nilai-tambah-yang-berkeadilan-dalam-pertambangan.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Olan'g |first1=Thomas Scurfield, Matthieu Salomon, Silas |title=Enam Kunci untuk Mewujudkan Nilai Tambah yang Berkeadilan dalam Pertambangan |publisher=Natural Resource Governance Institute |date=25 November 2024 |url=https://resourcegovernance.org/id/publications/enam-kunci-untuk-mewujudkan-nilai-tambah-yang-berkeadilan-dalam-pertambangan |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document NRGI-000011)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{olang2024enam, author = {Olan'g, Thomas Scurfield, Matthieu Salomon, Silas}, title = {{Enam Kunci untuk Mewujudkan Nilai Tambah yang Berkeadilan dalam Pertambangan}}, institution = {Natural Resource Governance Institute}, year = {2024}, month = nov, url = {https://resourcegovernance.org/id/publications/enam-kunci-untuk-mewujudkan-nilai-tambah-yang-berkeadilan-dalam-pertambangan}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document NRGI-000011} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated