Search Climate Insights Directory

The document presents three implementation pathways (low, medium, and high levels) for a UBIG in South Africa, arguing that such a grant would reduce poverty and stimulate economic growth. It details the fiscal impact, suggesting that while gross costs are high, net costs are lower due to VAT returns and proposed progressive taxes, including a social security tax and wealth taxes.

The document outlines three financial pathways (low, medium, and high effort) to implement a Universal Basic Income Guarantee (UBIG) for South Africans aged 18 to 59. Using a simulation model developed with Applied Development Research Solutions (ADRS), the Institute for Economic Justice (IEJ) argues that a UBIG is fiscally sustainable and would stimulate economic growth, reduce poverty, and lower unemployment. The analysis suggests that while gross costs are high, the net cost is significantly reduced by VAT returns and a proposed social security tax (SST). Funding mechanisms include progressive wealth taxes on the top 1% of the population, luxury VAT, and the reduction of tax subsidies for pensions and medical aid.

The Institute for Economic Justice (IEJ) identifies four critical failures in South Africa's tax management: significant revenue shortfalls (approximately R50bn in 2018), the undermining of the South African Revenue Service (SARS) by corruption and state capture, a tax mix that under-taxes wealth and corporate income, and high levels of illicit financial flows. The brief proposes increasing Personal Income Tax (PIT) and Corporate Income Tax (CIT) rates, introducing a permanent net wealth tax (0.5%-2.5%), and expanding VAT zero-rating for 23 categories of essential goods to support low-income households. To recover lost revenue, the IEJ recommends revitalizing SARS through a Presidential Commission, reintroducing a special priority crime unit, and increasing transparency of corporate and offshore structures. These measures are intended to fund a fiscal stimulus, public employment guarantees, and social services to enhance job creation.