WORKING PAPER FOR THE PRESIDENTIAL CLIMATE COMMISSION POLICY PRIMERS FOR A SOUTH AFRICAN JUST TRANSITION FRAMEWORK
Summary
The document argues that South Africa's current just transition efforts are largely limited to managerial reforms for workers and must evolve toward a more ambitious transformative agenda that integrates social, environmental, and economic justice.
Key insights
- Current just transition debates in South Africa primarily focus on a 'managerial reform agenda' centered on distributive justice for workers, failing to address the root causes of inequality or historical damages.
- South Africa has not yet adopted a development pathway that is compatible with global climate goals, which is a fundamental prerequisite for any just transition discussion.
- Procedural justice in South Africa has shifted from genuine grassroots, citizen-led decision-making toward 'managerialist and technocratic interpretations' in policy implementation.
- The Unemployment Insurance Fund (UIF) provides an imperfect safety net, as only 60% of employed people contributed in 2018 and it does not adequately cover workers with low job tenure, such as youth and informal workers.
- South African industrial policy often contradicts green transition goals, exemplified by the Musina-Makhado SEZ in Limpopo, which plans for industrial facilities powered by a large coal-fired power plant.
- Direct fossil fuel subsidies in South Africa amounted to 2% of GDP in 2017, increasing to 13.6% when the cost of externalities is included.
- Social grant systems, while reducing poverty, are insufficient for climate resilience; for example, the child support grant would only lift half a person out of poverty.
- Restorative justice is often overlooked but is essential for addressing historical inequalities; currently, asset ownership remains highly skewed, with the top decile of households owning 61% of business assets as of 2015.
- Mining operations in Mpumalanga have caused significant land loss; in 2013, 74% of the province's highest-value agricultural land was subject to mining and prospection applications.
- Environmental restoration is critical in areas like the Vaal Triangle, which has the most polluted air in the country due to coal mines, heavy industries, and power stations.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Montmasson-Clair, G. (2021). WORKING PAPER FOR THE PRESIDENTIAL CLIMATE COMMISSION POLICY PRIMERS FOR A SOUTH AFRICAN JUST TRANSITION FRAMEWORK. Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies. https://tips.org.za/images/Working_Paper_PCC_Policy_primers_for_a_Just_Transition_framework_2021.pdf
- Chicago
- Montmasson-Clair, Gaylor. WORKING PAPER FOR THE PRESIDENTIAL CLIMATE COMMISSION POLICY PRIMERS FOR A SOUTH AFRICAN JUST TRANSITION FRAMEWORK. Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies, 2021. https://tips.org.za/images/Working_Paper_PCC_Policy_primers_for_a_Just_Transition_framework_2021.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Montmasson-Clair |first1=Gaylor |title=WORKING PAPER FOR THE PRESIDENTIAL CLIMATE COMMISSION POLICY PRIMERS FOR A SOUTH AFRICAN JUST TRANSITION FRAMEWORK |publisher=Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies |date=October 2021 |url=https://tips.org.za/images/Working_Paper_PCC_Policy_primers_for_a_Just_Transition_framework_2021.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document tipsza-000703)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{montmassonclair2021working, author = {Montmasson-Clair, Gaylor}, title = {{WORKING PAPER FOR THE PRESIDENTIAL CLIMATE COMMISSION POLICY PRIMERS FOR A SOUTH AFRICAN JUST TRANSITION FRAMEWORK}}, institution = {Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies}, year = {2021}, month = oct, url = {https://tips.org.za/images/Working_Paper_PCC_Policy_primers_for_a_Just_Transition_framework_2021.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document tipsza-000703} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated