The ratings downgrade
Summary
The document argues that while the credit downgrade theoretically accelerates capital outflows and increases borrowing costs, these effects were largely overshadowed by the COVID-19 pandemic. It critiques the ratings agencies for ignoring the role of falling global metal prices in South Africa's slow growth and argues that their policy recommendations—such as cutting government spending and reducing worker protections—are contradictory because they would aggravate the social inequalities that contribute to investor uncertainty.
Key insights
- The primary direct economic impact of the downgrade is the acceleration of financial investment outflows, which puts downward pressure on the rand, increases international borrowing costs, and lowers share prices.
- The economic consequences of the downgrade vary by sector: financial institutions and importers of consumer and intermediate goods are the primary losers, while exporters and local producers competing with imports stand to gain from currency depreciation.
- The immediate effects of the ratings downgrade were largely eclipsed by the COVID-19 pandemic, which had already triggered massive capital outflows, reduced demand for exports, and lowered the international cost of crude oil.
- The author argues that the ratings agencies' justification for the downgrade ignores the critical role of the 2011 collapse in global mining prices, which significantly dragged down South Africa's GDP growth.
- The policy recommendations suggested by ratings agencies to reverse the downgrade—including reducing worker protections, limiting land reform, and cutting government spending—are viewed as contradictory because they would likely increase social inequality and long-term investor risk.
- South Africa's vulnerability to international financial fluctuations is heightened by a historical reliance on portfolio investment over foreign direct investment, resulting in a Johannesburg Stock Exchange market capitalization that was more than twice the GDP in 2018.
- Moody's specifically cited several factors for the downgrade, including unreliable electricity supply, structural labour market rigidities, threats to property rights from land reform, rising government debt, and institutional erosion caused by state capture.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Makgetla, N. (2020). The ratings downgrade. Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies. https://tips.org.za/images/TIPS_Policy_Brief_The_ratings_downgrade_April_2020.pdf
- Chicago
- Makgetla, Neva. The ratings downgrade. Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies, 2020. https://tips.org.za/images/TIPS_Policy_Brief_The_ratings_downgrade_April_2020.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Makgetla |first1=Neva |title=The ratings downgrade |publisher=Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies |date=April 2020 |url=https://tips.org.za/images/TIPS_Policy_Brief_The_ratings_downgrade_April_2020.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document tipsza-000645)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{makgetla2020ratings, author = {Makgetla, Neva}, title = {{The ratings downgrade}}, institution = {Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies}, year = {2020}, month = apr, url = {https://tips.org.za/images/TIPS_Policy_Brief_The_ratings_downgrade_April_2020.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document tipsza-000645} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated