Structural change, productivity growth and employment: South African development in comparative perspective
Summary
The paper examines the 'middle income trap'—where economies stagnate at middle-income levels—and analyzes productivity drivers in South Africa and other BRICS countries. It argues that South Africa's productivity growth has been driven primarily by 'within-sector' improvements rather than propulsive structural change, often resulting in labour shedding and increased informality. The authors contrast orthodox views, which emphasize market-driven convergence, with heterodox views that advocate for a 'developmental state' to create comparative advantage through industrial and technology policies. Findings suggest that in South Africa, productivity growth and employment growth often occur in different subsectors, indicating a lack of 'propulsive' growth that simultaneously increases both.
Key insights
- The 'middle income trap' is characterized as a phenomenon where economies stagnate at middle-income levels and fail to transition into high-income status, often due to difficulties in shifting production to more productive sectors.
- There is significant academic disagreement regarding the definition of the middle income trap, with different studies using varying income thresholds and criteria for growth deceleration to identify affected countries.
- In South Africa, economy-wide labour productivity growth has been primarily driven by 'within-sector' productivity improvements rather than structural shifts (the movement of labour from low to high productivity sectors).
- South Africa's pattern of productivity growth is associated with negative employment outcomes, including labour shedding, a rise in the informal sector, and an increase in employment within low value-added services.
- The authors identify a '21st Century paradox' where high levels of productivity growth and capital accumulation do not necessarily absorb labour, potentially leading to 'adverse' structural change where workers spill over into low-productivity sectors or unemployment.
- Comparative analysis suggests that South Africa's experience of structural change and productivity growth shares more similarities with India than with Brazil.
- The paper argues that for South Africa to escape stagnation, it requires a coherent combination of trade, industrial, and technology policies to foster 'learning-by-doing' in increasing-returns activities, alongside a 'decent work' agenda.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Fryer, D., & Cattaneo, N. (n.d.). Structural change, productivity growth and employment: South African development in comparative perspective. Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies. https://forum.tips.org.za/images/forum%20papers/2014/58c2c3_21d3c2451d75488b8f0b44719c5e55e0.pdf
- Chicago
- Fryer, David, and Nicolette Cattaneo. Structural change, productivity growth and employment: South African development in comparative perspective. Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies, n.d. https://forum.tips.org.za/images/forum%20papers/2014/58c2c3_21d3c2451d75488b8f0b44719c5e55e0.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Fryer |first1=David |last2=Cattaneo |first2=Nicolette |title=Structural change, productivity growth and employment: South African development in comparative perspective |publisher=Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies |url=https://forum.tips.org.za/images/forum%20papers/2014/58c2c3_21d3c2451d75488b8f0b44719c5e55e0.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document tipsza-000180)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{fryerndstructural, author = {Fryer, David and Cattaneo, Nicolette}, title = {{Structural change, productivity growth and employment: South African development in comparative perspective}}, institution = {Trade and Industrial Policy Strategies}, url = {https://forum.tips.org.za/images/forum%20papers/2014/58c2c3_21d3c2451d75488b8f0b44719c5e55e0.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document tipsza-000180} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated