What is the Missing Ingredient?
Summary
The document evaluates Germany's 2025 agricultural strategy for Africa, finding that while it progressively adopts agroecology, it fails to explicitly integrate food sovereignty and address the structural inequities of global trade and land tenure.
Key insights
- The BMEL 2025 strategy marks a progressive shift by placing agroecology at the heart of its approach, defining it as an integrated system incorporating social, economic, and ecological dimensions.
- The strategy fails to explicitly integrate food sovereignty as a core pillar, treating it instead as a mere alternative to industrial agriculture, which risks reinforcing dependencies on external markets and inputs.
- There is a significant gap in the strategy regarding the high costs of organic certification for smallholders in Africa; the authors suggest Participatory Guarantee Systems (PGS) as a farmer-led, cost-effective alternative.
- The strategy's focus on digitalisation and mechanisation may be limited if it does not address structural constraints like insecure land tenure and the lack of local manufacturing for agricultural equipment within Africa.
- The BMEL strategy does not sufficiently address the structural imbalances of global agricultural trade, such as the impact of European agricultural exports on African local value chains and the distorting effect of subsidies in developed nations.
- While the strategy moves toward a 'concept with Africa' through multi-stakeholder engagement, it risks becoming a procedural formality if it does not actively mitigate power imbalances between large industry associations and smallholder cooperatives.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Adil, L., Thorp, A. G., Opfer, K., Otieno, F., & Maiyah, J. I. (2025). What is the Missing Ingredient? Power Shift Africa. https://www.powershiftafrica.org/s/RZ_Resilienz_Africa_WEB.pdf
- Chicago
- Adil, Lina, Amy Giliam Thorp, Kerstin Opfer, Fredrick Otieno, and Juma Ignatius Maiyah. What is the Missing Ingredient? Power Shift Africa, 2025. https://www.powershiftafrica.org/s/RZ_Resilienz_Africa_WEB.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Adil |first1=Lina |last2=Thorp |first2=Amy Giliam |last3=Opfer |first3=Kerstin |last4=Otieno |first4=Fredrick |last5=Maiyah |first5=Juma Ignatius |title=What is the Missing Ingredient? |publisher=Power Shift Africa |date=March 2025 |url=https://www.powershiftafrica.org/s/RZ_Resilienz_Africa_WEB.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document powshift-000075)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{adil2025what, author = {Adil, Lina and Thorp, Amy Giliam and Opfer, Kerstin and Otieno, Fredrick and Maiyah, Juma Ignatius}, title = {{What is the Missing Ingredient?}}, institution = {Power Shift Africa}, year = {2025}, month = mar, url = {https://www.powershiftafrica.org/s/RZ_Resilienz_Africa_WEB.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document powshift-000075} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated