Receptivity and judgement: expanding ways of knowing the climate to strengthen the resilience of cities
Summary
The authors argue that the uptake of climate information depends on the 'receptivity' of decision-makers and scientists—an active, critical engagement with alternative perspectives—rather than a linear transfer of data. Using the FRACTAL project's 'Learning Labs' in Maputo, Windhoek, and Lusaka, the paper demonstrates how participatory, embodied, and co-productive methods can expand 'sense-making vocabularies' and foster reflective judgement, enabling actors to move beyond 'business-as-usual' practices toward climate-resilient urban development.
Key insights
- The authors argue that the effectiveness of climate information in decision-making is not determined by the volume of data provided, but by the 'receptivity' of the actors involved. Receptivity is defined as an active, critical, and reflexive engagement with alternative perspectives and ways of knowing, rather than a passive state of openness.
- The paper suggests that developing a 'receptive stance' allows actors to acquire new 'sense-making vocabularies'. These vocabularies enable decision-makers to see beyond 'business-as-usual' constraints and recognize new possibilities for social change and climate-resilient futures.
- To foster receptivity, the authors advocate for 'aesthetic/affective' and embodied engagement methods over conventional verbal/cognitive approaches. They argue that performative practices, such as role-playing, create a sense of safety that reduces defensiveness and encourages participants to risk their established frames of reference.
- Evidence from FRACTAL Learning Labs in Maputo, Windhoek, and Lusaka indicates that co-production processes increase the receptivity of both city stakeholders and climate scientists. Scientists, in particular, became more open to non-biophysical knowledge when engaging with the complexity of urban decision spaces.
- The paper identifies that climate change is often viewed as a low-priority 'add-on' in southern African cities compared to immediate development goals like poverty reduction and infrastructure provision. Fostering receptivity requires acknowledging this reality and integrating climate considerations as cross-cutting issues.
- The authors propose 'climate information distillation' as a way to enhance receptivity. This involves democratically agreeing on the 'essential meaning' of climate data with multiple actors, including decision-makers, to avoid the confusion caused by opaque, conflicting expert reports.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Scott, D., & Taylor, A. (2019). Receptivity and judgement: expanding ways of knowing the climate to strengthen the resilience of cities. Future Climate for Africa. http://www.fractal.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Scott-D-and-Taylor-A-Receptivity-and-Judgement-web.pdf
- Chicago
- Scott, Dianne, and Anna Taylor. Receptivity and judgement: expanding ways of knowing the climate to strengthen the resilience of cities. Future Climate for Africa, 2019. http://www.fractal.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Scott-D-and-Taylor-A-Receptivity-and-Judgement-web.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Scott |first1=Dianne |last2=Taylor |first2=Anna |title=Receptivity and judgement: expanding ways of knowing the climate to strengthen the resilience of cities |publisher=Future Climate for Africa |date=January 2019 |url=http://www.fractal.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Scott-D-and-Taylor-A-Receptivity-and-Judgement-web.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document futcliaf-000263)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{scott2019receptivity, author = {Scott, Dianne and Taylor, Anna}, title = {{Receptivity and judgement: expanding ways of knowing the climate to strengthen the resilience of cities}}, institution = {Future Climate for Africa}, year = {2019}, month = jan, url = {http://www.fractal.org.za/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Scott-D-and-Taylor-A-Receptivity-and-Judgement-web.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document futcliaf-000263} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated