A Comparative Review of Housing Energy Efficiency Interventions
Summary
The document assesses a wide range of energy efficiency mechanisms—including regulations, grants, loans, and tax incentives—across various jurisdictions. It highlights the effectiveness of different models, such as Germany's KfW loans and France's CITE tax credits, while examining the challenges of fuel poverty and the 'split incentive' problem between landlords and tenants.
Key insights
- Germany's KfW Energy-efficient Refurbishment programme provides two distinct funding routes: low-interest loans up to €100,000 blended with repayment bonuses up to €27,500, or investment grants up to €30,000. The programme is highly rated for impact, with 1/3 of refurbishments in Germany receiving financial support under this scheme.
- France's Energy Transition Tax Credit (CITE) provides a subsidy covering 30% of refurbishment costs, capped at €8,000 for individuals or €16,000 for couples. The scheme is noted for its high popularity and effectiveness in communication, though it is criticized for primarily benefiting wealthier homeowners who are more likely to renovate.
- In Ireland, the Better Energy Warmer Homes scheme targets fuel poverty by providing 100% government-funded installations of attic insulation, draught proofing, and other measures for eligible vulnerable households. By the end of 2014, the scheme had upgraded more than 112,000 homes with a total spend of nearly €137 million.
- New Zealand's Warm Up New Zealand: Heat Smart programme demonstrated that health benefits significantly outweigh energy savings, with a cost-benefit analysis showing that 99% of the programme's benefits were health-related. The programme successfully insulated 235,000 homes, exceeding its initial target of 188,500.
- The Netherlands employs a Home Valuation System that links maximum rental prices to a property's energy label rating. This mechanism is designed to solve the 'split incentive' problem by providing landlords with a financial incentive to invest in energy efficiency through higher permissible rents.
- Sweden's RCE Allowance (ROT) provides a tax reduction of 50% for costs related to repairing, maintaining, converting, or extending properties, capped at SEK 50,000 per owner per year. While it supports energy efficiency, it has led to perverse incentives where contractors artificially inflate labour costs to increase the rebate.
- In Oregon, USA, the Clean Energy Works (CEWO) programme uses a 'one-stop-shop' model providing free energy assessments and bundled financing. While successful in job creation—supporting over 1,000 workers—it has been criticized by the Energy Trust of Oregon as the least cost-effective vehicle for delivering residential energy savings.
- France's Eco-PTZ (zero-interest loan) was considered largely unsuccessful due to the fact that banks, who managed the loans, were reluctant to distribute them due to extensive paperwork and low returns, and many applicants were refused based on solvency criteria.
- The Irish Home Renovation Incentive (HRI) provides a 13.5% income tax credit on qualifying expenditure up to €30,000 per property. Up to April 2015, it received registrations for over 20,000 works with a value exceeding €385 million, primarily aiming to boost the legitimate construction sector.
- Germany's Energy Conservation Regulations (EnEV) mandate minimum energy efficiency standards for new builds and major renovations. The 2013 Ordinance reduced building energy requirements by 30% and introduced an obligation to provide an 'Energy Pass' to buyers or new tenants.
- The Netherlands' 'More with Less' programme is a voluntary agreement that uses a website to help building owners identify savings measures and find registered installers. It is estimated to have improved the efficiency of about 1.2 million homes by 20-30% between 2008 and 2012.
- Sweden's LAGAN programme focuses on 'soft' measures rather than direct construction subsidies, funding demonstration projects and knowledge exchange to stimulate the supply chain for very low energy buildings. It requires projects to achieve at least 50% better energy performance than the Building Code for new builds.
- In New Zealand, the ENERGYWISE information campaigns and 'Energy Spot' TV series have high reach; 41% of viewers reported taking action to reduce energy use as a result of the TV episodes.
- France's 'White Certificates' (CEE) scheme obligates energy providers to meet triannual energy savings targets. In its first period, the scheme produced 65.3 TWh cumac of savings, with 86.7% coming from the residential sector.
- The Irish Energy Efficiency Obligation Scheme (EEOS) requires suppliers selling more than 600GWh to meet savings targets, with 25% of those savings mandated for the residential sector and 5% specifically for alleviating energy poverty.
- The Netherlands' Energy Tax, introduced in 1996, levies a tax on electricity and gas to encourage conservation. However, the price elasticity of demand is low (-0.1 to -0.25), meaning price increases lead to relatively small reductions in demand.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Rosenow, J., & Porter, F. (2015). A Comparative Review of Housing Energy Efficiency Interventions. ClimateXChange. https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/comparative_review_of_housing_energy_efficiency_interventions_appendices.pdf
- Chicago
- Rosenow, Jan, and Fiona Porter. A Comparative Review of Housing Energy Efficiency Interventions. ClimateXChange, 2015. https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/comparative_review_of_housing_energy_efficiency_interventions_appendices.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Rosenow |first1=Jan |last2=Porter |first2=Fiona |title=A Comparative Review of Housing Energy Efficiency Interventions |publisher=ClimateXChange |date=26 October 2015 |url=https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/comparative_review_of_housing_energy_efficiency_interventions_appendices.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document climex-000214)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{rosenow2015comparative, author = {Rosenow, Jan and Porter, Fiona}, title = {{A Comparative Review of Housing Energy Efficiency Interventions}}, institution = {ClimateXChange}, year = {2015}, month = oct, url = {https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/comparative_review_of_housing_energy_efficiency_interventions_appendices.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document climex-000214} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated