Governing large-scale carbon dioxide removal: are we ready?
Summary
The report argues that while some reporting and accounting rules exist under the UNFCCC, Kyoto Protocol, and Paris Agreement, significant governance gaps remain for the unprecedented scale of CDR required to limit warming to 1.5°C. It highlights that the level of future CDR reliance depends on the speed of near-term emissions reductions and identifies ten key challenges, including technology readiness, sustainable development trade-offs, and the lack of economic incentives. The authors recommend priority actions such as narrowing the mitigation gap, improving inventory data, and establishing robust accounting rules to avoid double counting.
Key insights
- To limit global warming to 1.5°C with limited or no overshoot, the IPCC projects a need for Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) on a scale of 100–1000 GtCO2 over the 21st century.
- The amount of CDR required is inversely related to the speed of emissions reductions; delaying mitigation increases the necessary scale of CDR, potentially reaching levels that jeopardize sustainable development or become economically unfeasible.
- Current international governance is fragmented, with significant differences in GHG inventory reporting between developed (Annex I) and developing (Non-Annex I) countries, which hinders the ability to aggregate data and assess global progress toward a balance of emissions and removals.
- The report identifies ten primary governance challenges for large-scale CDR: the rapid pace of scale-up required, responsibility and ethics, lack of deployment incentives, monitoring information gaps, sustainable development safeguards, measurement and verification (MRV) difficulties, storage permanence and leakage, biophysical effects, liability and redress, and public awareness.
- Large-scale land-based CDR options, such as Afforestation and Reforestation (A/R) and BECCS, present significant risks to sustainable development goals, including potential threats to food security, water security, and biodiversity.
- There is a critical lack of economic incentives and direct funding to accelerate the research, development, and commercialization of CDR technologies, particularly for those at low technology readiness levels.
- Existing IPCC guidelines provide substantial guidance for CCS and the land sector, but there is a notable absence of reporting guidance for newer CDR methods such as Direct Air Capture with Carbon Capture and Storage (DACCS).
- The report recommends several near-term priority actions, including the adoption of common GHG reporting metrics and formats, the elaboration of robust land sector accounting rules to prevent asymmetric accounting, and the use of external datasets (e.g., satellite data) to verify reported removals.
Cite the original document
- APA
- M.J., M., C.L., F., M., S., & W.L., H. (2018). Governing large-scale carbon dioxide removal: are we ready? Climate Analytics. https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/c2g2-2018-cdr-governance-1_1_1.pdf?v=1679478294
- Chicago
- M.J., Mace,, Fyson, C.L., Schaeffer, M., and Hare, W.L. Governing large-scale carbon dioxide removal: are we ready? Climate Analytics, 2018. https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/c2g2-2018-cdr-governance-1_1_1.pdf?v=1679478294.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=M.J. |first1=Mace, |last2=C.L. |first2=Fyson, |last3=M. |first3=Schaeffer, |last4=W.L. |first4=Hare, |title=Governing large-scale carbon dioxide removal: are we ready? |publisher=Climate Analytics |date=November 2018 |url=https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/c2g2-2018-cdr-governance-1_1_1.pdf?v=1679478294 |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document climanal-000321)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{mj2018governing, author = {M.J., Mace, and C.L., Fyson, and M., Schaeffer, and W.L., Hare,}, title = {{Governing large-scale carbon dioxide removal: are we ready?}}, institution = {Climate Analytics}, year = {2018}, month = nov, url = {https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/c2g2-2018-cdr-governance-1_1_1.pdf?v=1679478294}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document climanal-000321} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated