Governing large-scale carbon dioxide removal: are we ready? - an update
Summary
The report finds that while some reporting and accounting rules exist, significant governance gaps in incentives, monitoring, and sustainability safeguards remain, making the international community largely unprepared for the scale of CDR required to limit warming to 1.5°C.
Key insights
- To avoid or limit overshoot of the 1.5°C temperature goal, CO2 emissions must be phased out almost entirely by 2050, with a balance between emissions and removals reached by 2070.
- The amount of CDR needed is inversely related to the speed of near-term emissions reductions; delayed mitigation increases the required scale of CDR, potentially to levels that are economically unfeasible or jeopardize sustainable development.
- A diverse portfolio of CDR options is necessary to avoid the inherent limitations and sustainability risks associated with relying on any single method.
- Current international governance under the UNFCCC, Kyoto Protocol, and Paris Agreement provides some reporting and accounting rules, but these were not designed for the unprecedented scale of CDR now required.
- Significant governance gaps exist across ten key areas, including the rapid pace of scale-up, ethical responsibility for implementation, access to monitoring information, sustainable development safeguards, and the lack of sufficient economic incentives.
- Land-based CDR options, such as Afforestation/Reforestation (A/R) and BECCS, face substantial risks of non-permanence due to climate-driven disturbances like droughts and forest fires, as well as potential negative biophysical effects such as albedo changes.
- There is a lack of clear assignment of responsibility among UNFCCC Parties regarding who should fund and host CDR deployment, with equity-based burden-sharing potentially leading to different regional distributions than least-cost models.
- Current Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) are often ambiguous, not economy-wide, and lack clear accounting for the land sector, making it difficult to aggregate global progress toward the emissions-removals balance.
- Public acceptance of CDR is hindered by concerns over 'moral hazard'—the risk that the promise of future removals will be used to justify delaying urgent emissions reductions.
- Priority near-term governance actions include narrowing the 2030 mitigation gap, improving inventory data, establishing robust accounting rules for the land sector and Article 6 transfers, and creating direct financial incentives for CDR research and deployment.
Cite the original document
- APA
- M.J., M., C.L., F., M., S., & W.L., H. (2021). Governing large-scale carbon dioxide removal: are we ready? - an update. Climate Analytics. https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/are-we-ready_2021_fullreport.pdf?v=1679478354
- Chicago
- M.J., Mace,, Fyson, C.L., Schaeffer, M., and Hare, W.L. Governing large-scale carbon dioxide removal: are we ready? - an update. Climate Analytics, 2021. https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/are-we-ready_2021_fullreport.pdf?v=1679478354.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=M.J. |first1=Mace, |last2=C.L. |first2=Fyson, |last3=M. |first3=Schaeffer, |last4=W.L. |first4=Hare, |title=Governing large-scale carbon dioxide removal: are we ready? - an update |publisher=Climate Analytics |date=February 2021 |url=https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/are-we-ready_2021_fullreport.pdf?v=1679478354 |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document climanal-000280)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{mj2021governing, author = {M.J., Mace, and C.L., Fyson, and M., Schaeffer, and W.L., Hare,}, title = {{Governing large-scale carbon dioxide removal: are we ready? - an update}}, institution = {Climate Analytics}, year = {2021}, month = feb, url = {https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/are-we-ready_2021_fullreport.pdf?v=1679478354}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document climanal-000280} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated