That’s Incredible! The Contours of Budget Credibility in Nigeria
Summary
The document analyzes budget credibility in Nigeria from 2009 to 2016, finding that while oil revenue volatility is a factor, low credibility is primarily driven by unrealistic expenditure projections and underspending in capital projects within the economic sector. It highlights the role of legislative amendments in exacerbating underspending and notes that unrealistic budgeting is a larger driver of capital underspending than implementation failures.
Key insights
- Nigeria's federal budget consistently exhibits low credibility, characterized by under-collected revenues and actual spending that fails to meet approved targets. The central government underspent its budget by 16 percent in 2009 and by 27 percent in 2016.
- Ambitious expenditure projections are a primary driver of underspending. In seven out of nine years examined, years with above-average projected budget growth also experienced above-average credibility gaps.
- While oil revenue is a significant revenue source, it was only the majority factor in revenue under-collection in 2010 and 2011. Underperformance in customs revenue and 'independent revenue' (fees and service charges from independent agencies) accounted for more than half of under-collection in most years.
- Poor oil revenue projections are driven more by unrealistic production forecasts than by poor price forecasting; crude oil price assumptions were generally conservative, while production estimates were typically ambitious.
- The most severe credibility issues occur within the capital budget, specifically in the economic sector involving major infrastructure projects in energy, transport, and petroleum. Capital underspending accounted for between 62 percent and 149 percent of total underspending annually.
- Underspending in the capital budget is primarily caused by unrealistic budgeting rather than implementation failures. For example, in 2013, agencies spent 92 percent of released funds but only 58 percent of their total budgets.
- Legislative amendments often worsen budget credibility by introducing unfeasible projects. In 2010, the legislature increased the budget from the executive's N4.08 trillion proposal to N5.16 trillion, resulting in a variance of N1.11 trillion compared to a projected variance of only 32 billion against the original proposal.
- Wage expenditure generally maintains higher credibility than other budget areas, with an average underspend of less than two percent. There is little evidence that wage increases drive overall budget underspending, except for a specific case in 2010 involving unplanned increases and a supplementary budget of N644.75 billion.
- The use of the Excess Crude Account to cover budget shortfalls reduces the apparent size of the credibility gap but does not explain the variation in credibility between years, as it was primarily used in years that already had severe credibility challenges.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Atiku, S., & Lakin, J. (2019). That’s Incredible! The Contours of Budget Credibility in Nigeria. BudgIT. https://budgit.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/the-contours-of-budget-credibility-in-nigeria-ibp-2019.pdf
- Chicago
- Atiku, Samuel, and Jason Lakin. That’s Incredible! The Contours of Budget Credibility in Nigeria. BudgIT, 2019. https://budgit.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/the-contours-of-budget-credibility-in-nigeria-ibp-2019.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Atiku |first1=Samuel |last2=Lakin |first2=Jason |title=That’s Incredible! The Contours of Budget Credibility in Nigeria |publisher=BudgIT |date=March 2019 |url=https://budgit.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/the-contours-of-budget-credibility-in-nigeria-ibp-2019.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document budgit-000264)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{atiku2019thats, author = {Atiku, Samuel and Lakin, Jason}, title = {{That’s Incredible! The Contours of Budget Credibility in Nigeria}}, institution = {BudgIT}, year = {2019}, month = mar, url = {https://budgit.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/the-contours-of-budget-credibility-in-nigeria-ibp-2019.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document budgit-000264} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated