Approach with Caution: A learning process on three approaches to sustainable development
Summary
The document evaluates three methodologies for sustainable development: the Negotiated Approach (NA), Participatory Land Use Planning (PLUP), and the Rights Based Approach (RBA). The NA focuses on shifting river basin planning from the state to civil society through iterative negotiation and strategic management. PLUP aims to clarify land access and control, particularly in response to 'land grabs', using tools like participatory GIS mapping. The RBA utilizes legal frameworks and human rights to transform poverty alleviation from a voluntary act into a state obligation. The paper identifies challenges such as power imbalances, transaction costs, and the need for specific, justiciable legal standards, while emphasizing the role of tailored communication and community mobilization in achieving social and environmental justice.
Key insights
- The Negotiated Approach (NA) to Integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM) aims to shift the initiative for river basin planning from the state to civil society, asserting that local communities are capable of managing their own resources at both local and basin levels.
- The NA is distinguished from other participatory approaches by its starting point; it is initiated at the local level rather than by external agents, necessitating a power shift in decision-making where communities jointly develop plans rather than merely reacting to existing ones.
- Implementation of the NA relies on three central building blocks: knowledge development, the empowerment of local actors, and the creation of an enabling institutional, legal, and social environment for negotiations.
- Participatory Land Use Planning (PLUP) is used to clarify rights of access and control over land, often as a reactive measure to protect local users from expropriation or 'land grabs' by external investors and state agencies.
- A significant weakness of the counter-mapping movement within PLUP, specifically noted in West Kalimantan, Indonesia, is its limited ability to influence formal political landscapes or decision-making at district, provincial, or national levels.
- The Rights Based Approach (RBA) frames poverty alleviation as a legal obligation of states and donors under international law rather than a voluntary development mechanism, utilizing the principle of equality before the law to counter inequality.
- The RBA distinguishes between substantive rights (the specific content of the right) and procedural rights (mechanisms for access to justice, such as participation and accountability).
- A critical challenge for the RBA is the lack of specificity in legal rights; rights that are formulated in vague terms are not 'justiciable', making it difficult for courts to pass judgement on infringements.
- Effective communication for these approaches requires tailoring messages to the audience; for example, the NA is 'sold' to policy makers by emphasizing conflict reduction and cost-effectiveness, while PLUP is presented to communities as a tool for land protection.
- The three approaches are complementary: the RBA provides the legal framework and pressure for rights recognition, while the NA and PLUP provide the proactive mechanisms for negotiation and planning to realize those rights.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Schmitz, T. (2012). Approach with Caution: A learning process on three approaches to sustainable development. Both ENDS. https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/document/5Both_ENDS_Working_Paper_Approach_with_caution.pdf
- Chicago
- Schmitz, Tobias. Approach with Caution: A learning process on three approaches to sustainable development. Both ENDS, 2012. https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/document/5Both_ENDS_Working_Paper_Approach_with_caution.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Schmitz |first1=Tobias |title=Approach with Caution: A learning process on three approaches to sustainable development |publisher=Both ENDS |date=August 2012 |url=https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/document/5Both_ENDS_Working_Paper_Approach_with_caution.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document bothends-000441)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{schmitz2012approach, author = {Schmitz, Tobias}, title = {{Approach with Caution: A learning process on three approaches to sustainable development}}, institution = {Both ENDS}, year = {2012}, month = aug, url = {https://www.bothends.org/uploaded_files/document/5Both_ENDS_Working_Paper_Approach_with_caution.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document bothends-000441} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated