A statement submitted by Michael Koen in support of evidence of the importance of free prior informed consent to communities in Africa
Summary
The statement by Michael Koen asserts that FPIC is essential for African communities to resist 'primitive accumulation' and the externalisation of production costs by corporate and state interests. It argues that the narrow international focus on 'indigeneity' creates an artificial hierarchy of rights that excludes many African customary communities who are equally vulnerable to displacement. Koen contends that without a genuine 'right to say no,' consultations are inadequate and negotiation becomes 'collective begging.' The document advocates for FPIC as a tool for democratic development planning, particularly for women, youth, and the elderly, and as a means to secure land tenure and ensure full cost accounting in development projects.
Key insights
- The current economic regime of natural resource extraction in Africa is characterised by 'primitive accumulation' and the externalisation of production costs onto citizens and affected communities, leading to increased marginalisation and impoverishment.
- The application of FPIC based strictly on 'indigeneity' is problematic in Africa because it creates an artificial hierarchy of rights that excludes customary communities, despite both groups sharing the same basis for claiming internally applicable laws.
- Rural displacement in Africa is described as traumatic and frequently fails to recreate the 'historic geosocial patterns' of a community, which often results in the intensification of poverty and the destruction of spiritual, emotional, and economic dependencies.
- Consultation is an insufficient standard for protecting communities; without the substantive power to refuse a project (a 'veto ability'), negotiations are likened to 'collective begging' rather than genuine bargaining.
- FPIC is particularly critical for women, youth, and the elderly, who are disproportionately vulnerable to the shocks induced by land use changes and are often excluded from development decision-making.
- Approximately 90% of Africa is governed by customary land tenure rather than formal title, making FPIC a vital mechanism for securing tenure and providing a defence against forced removals.
- The document highlights that in Mozambique, despite progressive land laws recognising customary law, the rise of the extractives sector and the use of relocation decrees (such as in Tete province) have undermined the intended negotiated development based on consent.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Koen, M. (n.d.). A statement submitted by Michael Koen in support of evidence of the importance of free prior informed consent to communities in Africa. Alternative Information & Development Centre. https://aidc.org.za/download/The-importance-of-FPIC-to-communities-in-Africa.pdf
- Chicago
- Koen, Michael. A statement submitted by Michael Koen in support of evidence of the importance of free prior informed consent to communities in Africa. Alternative Information & Development Centre, n.d. https://aidc.org.za/download/The-importance-of-FPIC-to-communities-in-Africa.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite press release |last1=Koen |first1=Michael |title=A statement submitted by Michael Koen in support of evidence of the importance of free prior informed consent to communities in Africa |publisher=Alternative Information & Development Centre |url=https://aidc.org.za/download/The-importance-of-FPIC-to-communities-in-Africa.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document aidcza-000134)}}
- BibTeX
- @misc{koenndstatement, author = {Koen, Michael}, title = {{A statement submitted by Michael Koen in support of evidence of the importance of free prior informed consent to communities in Africa}}, publisher = {Alternative Information \& Development Centre}, url = {https://aidc.org.za/download/The-importance-of-FPIC-to-communities-in-Africa.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document aidcza-000134} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated