State of Tax and Wage Evasion
Summary
The document examines how illicit financial flows (IFFs) and profit shifting undermine South Africa's tax base and wage levels. It critiques OECD-led reforms like the BEPS Action Plan as structurally flawed and lacking ambition, arguing that the 'arms-length principle' is obsolete. The author advocates for a paradigm shift toward a unitary tax system based on a global apportionment formula and recommends immediate transparency measures, including public registries of beneficial ownership and the disclosure of tax returns for all South Africans.
Key insights
- Illicit financial flows (IFFs) result in significant revenue losses for South Africa, with conservative estimates for trade-related IFFs of goods alone ranging around R100 billion annually. Other estimates suggest 4% of South Africa's GDP is lost to IFFs, amounting to R186.4bn in 2017.
- The document introduces the concept of 'wage evasion,' arguing that profit shifting by multinational companies (MNCs) allows them to artificially reduce the profits of local subsidiaries, which is then used to justify low wages and avoid commitments to living wages or community housing.
- Current international transparency initiatives, including the Automatic Exchange of Information (AEoI) and the Common Reporting Standard (CRS), are described as structurally flawed. Loopholes include the exclusion of real estate, art, and gold, as well as high ownership thresholds (25%) for reporting financial instruments.
- The author argues that the 'arms-length principle' used in international tax law is obsolete because it relies on the fiction that related entities within an MNC act as independent competitors. This complexity allows MNCs to use resources to avoid taxes and increases the cost of disputes for weaker states.
- A 'unitary tax system' is proposed as a paradigm shift, where corporate profits are taxed based on a global apportionment formula using real economic indicators such as payroll, local assets, and sales, rather than reported accounting profits.
- The document recommends the 'ABCD' of tax transparency for South Africa: Automatic Exchange of Information, Beneficial ownership disclosure in public registries, Country-by-country reporting, and the public disclosure of the tax returns of every South African.
- The report warns against the use of binding arbitration in tax disputes, characterizing it as a 'private form of justice' that results in a loss of national sovereignty and lacks the independence and transparency of official judges.
- Specific short-to-medium term solutions for South Africa include creating a state-owned compulsory mineral exporting agency to stop mineral trade mis-invoicing and implementing a digital service tax on 'e-giants' like Google and Amazon.
- A case study on Lonmin suggests that profit-shifting arrangements, including a 'Bermuda connection' and management fees paid to a UK entity, depleted funds that could have been used to meet wage demands and Social Labour Plan commitments.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Alternative Information & Development Centre (2019). State of Tax and Wage Evasion. https://aidc.org.za/download/Tax-Evasion-and-South-Africa.pdf
- Chicago
- Alternative Information & Development Centre. State of Tax and Wage Evasion. 2019. https://aidc.org.za/download/Tax-Evasion-and-South-Africa.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |author=Alternative Information & Development Centre |title=State of Tax and Wage Evasion |date=2019 |url=https://aidc.org.za/download/Tax-Evasion-and-South-Africa.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document aidcza-000132)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{alternativeinformationdevelopmentcentre2019state, author = {{Alternative Information \& Development Centre}}, title = {{State of Tax and Wage Evasion}}, institution = {Alternative Information \& Development Centre}, year = {2019}, url = {https://aidc.org.za/download/Tax-Evasion-and-South-Africa.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document aidcza-000132} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated