TRANSFER PRICING THE EROSION OF TAX, WAGE AND LOCAL INVESTMENT BASE IN SOUTH AFRICA
Summary
The Alternative Information and Development Centre (AIDC) contends that transfer pricing arrangements with low commercial substance lead to massive illicit capital outflows from South Africa. The document highlights how multinational enterprises (MNEs) use local subsidiaries to shift resources through exaggerated management fees, sales commissions, and inter-company loans to tax havens. Using case studies of Lonmin, Total Coal South Africa, and Barplats Mining, the AIDC illustrates how these practices deplete funds available for living wages and social obligations. The report critically assesses the 2008 Companies Act, arguing that reduced disclosure requirements for private companies shield these arrangements from public scrutiny. The AIDC proposes that all for-profit companies, especially MNE subsidiaries, be required to submit annual financial statements to the CIPC to ensure transparency and accountability.
Key insights
- Aggressive tax planning and transfer pricing do not only reduce tax revenue but also erode the financial base available for paying living wages and making local investments, contributing to social and labour market instability.
- The AIDC argues that the 2008 Companies Act has reduced transparency by removing the requirement for certain private companies, including subsidiaries of public companies, to submit their annual financial statements to the CIPC.
- In the case of Lonmin, the subsidiary Western Platinum Ltd (WPL) paid approximately R250 million annually in sales commissions and management fees between 2006 and 2012, which the AIDC claims lacked commercial substance.
- Lonmin's use of a 'Bermuda connection' via Western Metal Sales (WMS) was defended by company officials as a means of transferring risk, a claim the AIDC disputes based on financial statements showing risks remained with the producing entity.
- Total Coal South Africa (Pty) Ltd is alleged to use transfer pricing by levying a 4% 'marketing fee' on joint ventures with junior miners and paying a 7% 'sales commission' to a London-based trading arm of Total S.A.
- Total Coal South Africa further erodes the base of junior miners by charging them higher rates for rail and port infrastructure than it pays to Transnet, retaining the difference as profit.
- Barplats Mining Ltd's financial losses were significantly driven by interest payments on a R2.9 billion loan from Eastplats International Incorporated, a subsidiary based in the tax haven of Barbados.
- The AIDC identifies a 'Tradition of Acceptance' where tax auditors and auditing firms may overlook questionable transfer pricing if the fees are low enough in percentage terms or follow historical patterns.
- Illicit financial flows from Sub-Saharan Africa are estimated by Global Financial Integrity (2014) to be massive, with South Africa ranked as the 10th highest exporter of illicit capital.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Alternative Information & Development Centre (2015). TRANSFER PRICING THE EROSION OF TAX, WAGE AND LOCAL INVESTMENT BASE IN SOUTH AFRICA. https://aidc.org.za/download/aidcDTCsubmis11.pdf
- Chicago
- Alternative Information & Development Centre. TRANSFER PRICING THE EROSION OF TAX, WAGE AND LOCAL INVESTMENT BASE IN SOUTH AFRICA. 2015. https://aidc.org.za/download/aidcDTCsubmis11.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite press release |author=Alternative Information & Development Centre |title=TRANSFER PRICING THE EROSION OF TAX, WAGE AND LOCAL INVESTMENT BASE IN SOUTH AFRICA |date=16 April 2015 |url=https://aidc.org.za/download/aidcDTCsubmis11.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document aidcza-000115)}}
- BibTeX
- @misc{alternativeinformationdevelopmentcentre2015transfer, author = {{Alternative Information \& Development Centre}}, title = {{TRANSFER PRICING THE EROSION OF TAX, WAGE AND LOCAL INVESTMENT BASE IN SOUTH AFRICA}}, publisher = {Alternative Information \& Development Centre}, year = {2015}, month = apr, url = {https://aidc.org.za/download/aidcDTCsubmis11.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document aidcza-000115} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated