SBTi’s controversial shift has given a new lifeline to the carbon offset ruse
Summary
The author criticizes a decision by the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) board in April 2024 to allow corporations to use carbon offsets to meet climate targets, arguing that this facilitates greenwashing and allows companies to avoid changing polluting business models. The text highlights that unregulated carbon markets often result in low-quality projects that fail to benefit affected communities and can lead to human rights abuses, citing examples of land ownership fears in Liberia and reported sexual abuse at a project in Kenya. While noting that some governments, such as Zimbabwe, are introducing regulations to ensure a portion of carbon credit proceeds fund adaptation and loss and damage, the author contends that promoting carbon markets as 'climate finance' is a strategy by Global North governments and corporations to evade responsibility for climate change.
Key insights
- The author asserts that allowing the large-scale use of carbon offsets constitutes greenwashing, as it enables corporations to claim sustainability leadership through projects like tree-planting while maintaining polluting business models. This is supported by an Oxfam study indicating that insufficient land exists to support the level of offsetting required for net zero.
- Unregulated carbon markets are described as primarily benefiting corporations seeking cheap ways to meet targets and developers, rather than the communities most impacted by climate change. The author cites a deal by Dubai-based Blue Carbon LLC involving forested land in at least five African countries equivalent in size to the UK.
- Carbon offsetting projects have been linked to human rights violations, including the threat to community land ownership in Liberia and reports of sexual abuse at the Kasigau carbon offset project in Kenya, which led to a temporary suspension by Verra.
- Zimbabwe has implemented carbon credits regulation in 2023 that mandates 30% of trading proceeds go toward an 'environment levy', with 55% of that levy dedicated to low carbon projects and climate adaptation, and 5% for loss and damage.
- The author claims that Global North governments, specifically mentioning lobbying by former US Climate Envoy John Kerry's office to support the Energy Transition Accelerator, use carbon markets to avoid taking responsibility for climate chaos.
Cite the original document
- APA
- N’zi-Hassane, F. (2024). SBTi’s controversial shift has given a new lifeline to the carbon offset ruse. African Arguments. https://africanarguments.org/2024/07/sbti-controversial-shift-has-given-a-new-lifeline-to-the-carbon-offsets-ruse/
- Chicago
- N’zi-Hassane, Fati. SBTi’s controversial shift has given a new lifeline to the carbon offset ruse. African Arguments, 2024. https://africanarguments.org/2024/07/sbti-controversial-shift-has-given-a-new-lifeline-to-the-carbon-offsets-ruse/.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite press release |last1=N’zi-Hassane |first1=Fati |title=SBTi’s controversial shift has given a new lifeline to the carbon offset ruse |publisher=African Arguments |date=30 July 2024 |url=https://africanarguments.org/2024/07/sbti-controversial-shift-has-given-a-new-lifeline-to-the-carbon-offsets-ruse/ |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document afriarg-000092)}}
- BibTeX
- @misc{nzihassane2024sbtis, author = {N’zi-Hassane, Fati}, title = {{SBTi’s controversial shift has given a new lifeline to the carbon offset ruse}}, publisher = {African Arguments}, year = {2024}, month = jul, url = {https://africanarguments.org/2024/07/sbti-controversial-shift-has-given-a-new-lifeline-to-the-carbon-offsets-ruse/}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document afriarg-000092} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated