From Kyiv to Kinshasa: Five Lessons for Governments Navigating Mineral-for-Security Deals
Summary
The paper analyzes the emerging trend of linking mineral resources to security diplomacy, specifically examining the Ukraine-U.S. deal and potential agreements in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC). It argues that while short-term security needs often drive these deals, governments must prioritize transparency, look beyond political rhetoric to actual contractual obligations, rigorously value resources against the benefits received, and ensure that immediate concessions do not undermine long-term development goals or sovereignty.
Key insights
- Transparency is critical for building public trust and preventing corruption in state-to-state mineral deals, yet full disclosure is often lacking. While the Ukrainian government published one main agreement with the U.S., key financial details regarding contributions and withdrawals remain hidden in an undisclosed 'LP agreement'.
- There is often a significant gap between the political rhetoric of mineral-security deals and their actual legal terms. For instance, while the U.S. White House suggested it would have first choice to acquire Ukrainian resources, the actual agreement specifies that preferential offtake terms apply only to certain projects and must be based on "market-based commercial terms".
- The perceived diplomatic and security benefits of a deal can outweigh the immediate material value of the resources traded. The Ukraine-U.S. agreement appears to have relieved pressure from the Trump administration and reopened the possibility of additional U.S. military assistance, regardless of whether significant resources change hands quickly.
- Valuing mineral resources against security or infrastructure benefits is exceptionally difficult due to geological uncertainty and the opacity of military assistance. The DRC's Sicomines deal is cited as an example where significant mineral wealth was traded for inadequate infrastructure.
- Governments must ensure that short-term security trade-offs do not permanently compromise long-term strategic goals. Ukraine sought to protect its EU accession ambitions, while the DRC faces the risk that a security deal involving Rwanda might prioritize the governing coalition's survival over long-term industrialization and value addition.
- The duration and termination clauses of these agreements can create long-term sustainability risks. The published Ukraine-U.S. agreement only terminates by mutual agreement and includes legal stabilization provisions, potentially making revenue contributions and offtake rights indefinite.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Heller, A. S. M. L. M. J. P. O. P. (2025). From Kyiv to Kinshasa: Five Lessons for Governments Navigating Mineral-for-Security Deals. Natural Resource Governance Institute. https://resourcegovernance.org/publications/kyiv-kinshasa-five-lessons-governments-navigating-mineral-security-deals
- Chicago
- Heller, Amir Shafaie, Moise Liboto Makuta, Jean Pierre Okenda, Patrick. From Kyiv to Kinshasa: Five Lessons for Governments Navigating Mineral-for-Security Deals. Natural Resource Governance Institute, 2025. https://resourcegovernance.org/publications/kyiv-kinshasa-five-lessons-governments-navigating-mineral-security-deals.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Heller |first1=Amir Shafaie, Moise Liboto Makuta, Jean Pierre Okenda, Patrick |title=From Kyiv to Kinshasa: Five Lessons for Governments Navigating Mineral-for-Security Deals |publisher=Natural Resource Governance Institute |date=27 June 2025 |url=https://resourcegovernance.org/publications/kyiv-kinshasa-five-lessons-governments-navigating-mineral-security-deals |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document NRGI-000151)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{heller2025from, author = {Heller, Amir Shafaie, Moise Liboto Makuta, Jean Pierre Okenda, Patrick}, title = {{From Kyiv to Kinshasa: Five Lessons for Governments Navigating Mineral-for-Security Deals}}, institution = {Natural Resource Governance Institute}, year = {2025}, month = jun, url = {https://resourcegovernance.org/publications/kyiv-kinshasa-five-lessons-governments-navigating-mineral-security-deals}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document NRGI-000151} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated