ZELA welcomes the renewed effort by US Security Exchange Commission (SEC) to enact mandatory disclosure rules for companies in the extractive sector
Summary
ZELA advocates for the US SEC to implement mandatory disclosure rules for extractive companies that match the standards of Canada, the EU, and Norway. The organization argues that granular, project-level data is essential for holding the Zimbabwean government and foreign corporations accountable, especially as Zimbabwe has declined to join the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI). ZELA provides examples of how existing data from Canada's ESTMA has been used to trace payments to local governments and influence national policy on export incentives.
Key insights
- ZELA argues that the proposed SEC Resource Extraction Rule is currently insufficient to fight corruption and opacity in resource-rich but economically poor countries. They contend that the rule should at least meet the standards of Canada, the European Union, and Norway, which require companies to disclose payments to every government agency and local, regional, and national government on a project-by-project basis.
- The lack of project-level disclosures prevents Zimbabwean citizens from verifying if the state is fulfilling its constitutional obligation under Section 13 (4) to ensure local communities benefit from resources in their localities. This data gap is exacerbated by the Zimbabwean government's refusal to join the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) and the failure of state-owned entities like the Zimbabwe Mining Development Corporation to produce timely reports.
- ZELA demonstrates the utility of project-level data through the use of Canada's Extractive Sector Transparency Measures Act (ESTMA) reports. In the Gwanda mining community, ESTMA data allowed residents to trace a $466,000 rural electrification levy paid by Caledonia Mining Corporation in 2016 and reveal that the local government received only 2.77% ($144,760) of the Blanket mine's total 2018 payments to governments ($5,227,855).
- Data-driven advocacy led by ZELA contributed to the 2019 removal of harmful export incentives for mining companies after analysis showed these incentives cost the government more than it earned from mineral royalties.
- Zimbabwe's extractive sector is a primary economic driver, accounting for over 50% of export earnings over the last decade, with a government target to grow earnings to $12 billion by 2023. However, the sector is marked by severe corruption, such as the estimated loss of US$15 billion from looting in Marange diamond mining operations mentioned by former President Robert Mugabe in 2016.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Zimbabwe Environmental Law Organisation (2020). ZELA welcomes the renewed effort by US Security Exchange Commission (SEC) to enact mandatory disclosure rules for companies in the extractive sector. https://zela.org/zela-welcomes-the-renewed-effort-by-us-security-exchange-commission-sec-to-enact-mandatory-disclosure-rules-for-companies-in-the-extractive-sector-3/
- Chicago
- Zimbabwe Environmental Law Organisation. ZELA welcomes the renewed effort by US Security Exchange Commission (SEC) to enact mandatory disclosure rules for companies in the extractive sector. 2020. https://zela.org/zela-welcomes-the-renewed-effort-by-us-security-exchange-commission-sec-to-enact-mandatory-disclosure-rules-for-companies-in-the-extractive-sector-3/.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite press release |author=Zimbabwe Environmental Law Organisation |title=ZELA welcomes the renewed effort by US Security Exchange Commission (SEC) to enact mandatory disclosure rules for companies in the extractive sector |date=13 March 2020 |url=https://zela.org/zela-welcomes-the-renewed-effort-by-us-security-exchange-commission-sec-to-enact-mandatory-disclosure-rules-for-companies-in-the-extractive-sector-3/ |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document zela-000218)}}
- BibTeX
- @misc{zimbabweenvironmentallaworganisation2020zela, author = {{Zimbabwe Environmental Law Organisation}}, title = {{ZELA welcomes the renewed effort by US Security Exchange Commission (SEC) to enact mandatory disclosure rules for companies in the extractive sector}}, publisher = {Zimbabwe Environmental Law Organisation}, year = {2020}, month = mar, url = {https://zela.org/zela-welcomes-the-renewed-effort-by-us-security-exchange-commission-sec-to-enact-mandatory-disclosure-rules-for-companies-in-the-extractive-sector-3/}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document zela-000218} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated