Impartiality of the Judiciary System: Recusal of Judicial Officers
Summary
This guide outlines the process for the recusal of judges and magistrates in Zimbabwe, emphasizing that the mere possibility of bias, rather than actual bias, is the objective test for removal from a case.
Key insights
- The impartiality of the judiciary is a core principle of the rule of law under Section 164(2) of the Constitution, which is particularly critical in public interest litigation involving government agents or ministers.
- Recusal can occur in two ways: a judicial officer may recuse themselves 'mero motu' (of their own free will), or a litigant may apply for the officer's recusal based on reasonable grounds of bias, prejudice, or conflict of interest.
- The legal test for recusal is objective; it requires proving the 'mere possibility of bias' and the perception created in the mind of 'right thinking people' rather than the applicant's subjective impression.
- Sustainable grounds for recusal include relationships (friendship or hostility) between the officer and parties, a personal interest in the case outcome, general suspicion of reasonable bias, personal feelings that prevent impartiality, or non-judicial comments that suggest unfairness.
- Litigants are advised to apply for recusal at the start of a trial to avoid wasting resources; if a recusal is granted late in the proceedings, the entire trial becomes void and must be restarted 'de novo'.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Dube, E. N. (2021). Impartiality of the Judiciary System: Recusal of Judicial Officers. Zimbabwe Environmental Law Organisation. https://zela.org/impartiality-of-the-judiciary-system-recusal-of-judicial-officers/
- Chicago
- Dube, Effort Nkazimulo. Impartiality of the Judiciary System: Recusal of Judicial Officers. Zimbabwe Environmental Law Organisation, 2021. https://zela.org/impartiality-of-the-judiciary-system-recusal-of-judicial-officers/.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Dube |first1=Effort Nkazimulo |title=Impartiality of the Judiciary System: Recusal of Judicial Officers |publisher=Zimbabwe Environmental Law Organisation |date=18 August 2021 |url=https://zela.org/impartiality-of-the-judiciary-system-recusal-of-judicial-officers/ |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document zela-000180)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{dube2021impartiality, author = {Dube, Effort Nkazimulo}, title = {{Impartiality of the Judiciary System: Recusal of Judicial Officers}}, institution = {Zimbabwe Environmental Law Organisation}, year = {2021}, month = aug, url = {https://zela.org/impartiality-of-the-judiciary-system-recusal-of-judicial-officers/}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document zela-000180} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated