Summary

AI-generated

This summary is written by a language model reading the source document. It is not the publisher's words and is not a substitute for the original.

Learn more about AI enrichment

This report concludes that Project Tundra is a high-risk venture likely to exceed its budget and fail to meet carbon capture targets, potentially leading to higher electricity rates for cooperative members.

Key insights

AI-generated

These insights are written by a language model reading the source document. They are not the publisher's words and are not a substitute for the original.

Learn more about AI enrichment
  • Minnkota Power's capital cost estimates for Project Tundra, ranging from $1 billion to $1.6 billion, are considered unreasonably optimistic when compared to the actual costs of the Petra Nova facility, which cost $1 billion for a smaller 240MW capacity.
  • The project relies on Fluor capture technology that has never been operated at a commercial scale for power plants, requiring a 10- to 100-fold scale-up that is likely to cause unanticipated construction and operational problems.
  • Historical data from the only two existing coal-fired carbon capture plants, Petra Nova and Boundary Dam 3, show they failed to achieve their 90% capture targets, with Petra Nova's net capture rate likely 70% or lower and Boundary Dam 3's average between 55% and 60%.
  • It is unlikely that federal 45Q tax credits will fully fund the project because tax equity investors apply discount rates to future credits, meaning the net present value of credits is likely only 57% to 80% of project costs.
  • Milton R. Young Unit 2 is already a high-cost generator; between 2011 and 2019, ratepayers paid an estimated $455 million more for its power than they would have if the power had been purchased from MISO markets.
  • The project's economic viability is threatened by the continued decline in prices and improved performance of wind, solar, and storage technologies in the MISO market, as well as persistently low natural gas prices.
  • Using captured CO2 for enhanced oil recovery (EOR) is highly risky due to oil price volatility, as evidenced by NRG mothballing the Petra Nova project in July 2020 due to low oil prices.
  • Geologic storage of CO2 also presents financial risks, as costs for drilling, compressing, injecting, and monitoring are estimated at $20-$25 per ton, which could make the $50-per-ton tax credit insufficient to cover costs.

Cite the original document

APA
Schlissel, D., & Wamsted, D. (2020). Project Tundra: A Step in the Wrong Direction. Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis. https://ieefa.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Project-Tundra_A-Step-in-the-Wrong-Direction_September-2020.pdf
Chicago
Schlissel, David, and Dennis Wamsted. Project Tundra: A Step in the Wrong Direction. Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis, 2020. https://ieefa.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Project-Tundra_A-Step-in-the-Wrong-Direction_September-2020.pdf.
Wikipedia
{{cite report |last1=Schlissel |first1=David |last2=Wamsted |first2=Dennis |title=Project Tundra: A Step in the Wrong Direction |publisher=Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis |date=September 2020 |url=https://ieefa.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Project-Tundra_A-Step-in-the-Wrong-Direction_September-2020.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document ieefa-001842)}}
BibTeX
@techreport{schlissel2020project, author = {Schlissel, David and Wamsted, Dennis}, title = {{Project Tundra: A Step in the Wrong Direction}}, institution = {Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis}, year = {2020}, month = sep, url = {https://ieefa.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/Project-Tundra_A-Step-in-the-Wrong-Direction_September-2020.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document ieefa-001842} }

Full text

Collected · Record updated