memorandum-on-costs-to-ratepayers-if-northwestern-energy-or-state-of-montana-purchase-colstrip-plant_-may-2016-ff4e5df55aeb2937.pdf
Summary
IEEFA finds that acquiring Colstrip Units 1, 2, and 3 would cost NorthWestern Energy ratepayers or Montana taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars more than purchasing power from the market, potentially exceeding $1.4 billion by 2030.
Key insights
- Acquiring Colstrip Units 1&2 would cost customers between $207 million and $414 million more than market power through 2022, and between $405 million and $810 million through 2030.
- Acquiring shares of Colstrip Unit 3 would result in ratepayers paying an additional $131 million to $287 million through 2022 compared to market power costs.
- The combined acquisition of Colstrip Units 1&2 and the 407 MW share of Colstrip Unit 3 would likely cost ratepayers or taxpayers over $700 million more through 2022 and over $1.4 billion more through 2030 than buying electricity from the market.
- The calculated costs above are understatements because they exclude environmental remediation and decommissioning (estimated at $134 to $195 million), annual capital expenditures (estimated at $75 million annually for 2017-2022 and $72 million for 2023-2030 for a 50% share), and carbon emission costs (estimated at $20 to $40 million annually starting in 2022).
- Colstrip's uneconomicity is driven by market forces, specifically the decline in natural gas prices and increased competition from renewable resources.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (n.d.). memorandum-on-costs-to-ratepayers-if-northwestern-energy-or-state-of-montana-purchase-colstrip-plant_-may-2016-ff4e5df55aeb2937.pdf. https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/resources/Memorandum-on-Costs-to-Ratepayers-if-NorthWestern-Energy-or-State-of-Montana-Purchase-Colstrip-Plant_-May-2016.pdf
- Chicago
- Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis. memorandum-on-costs-to-ratepayers-if-northwestern-energy-or-state-of-montana-purchase-colstrip-plant_-may-2016-ff4e5df55aeb2937.pdf. n.d. https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/resources/Memorandum-on-Costs-to-Ratepayers-if-NorthWestern-Energy-or-State-of-Montana-Purchase-Colstrip-Plant_-May-2016.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite press release |author=Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis |title=memorandum-on-costs-to-ratepayers-if-northwestern-energy-or-state-of-montana-purchase-colstrip-plant_-may-2016-ff4e5df55aeb2937.pdf |url=https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/resources/Memorandum-on-Costs-to-Ratepayers-if-NorthWestern-Energy-or-State-of-Montana-Purchase-Colstrip-Plant_-May-2016.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document ieefa-001717)}}
- BibTeX
- @misc{instituteforenergyeconomicsandfinancialanalysisndmemorandumoncoststoratepayersifnorthwesternenergyorstateofmontanapurchasecolstripplantmay2016ff4e5df55aeb2937pdf, author = {{Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis}}, title = {{memorandum-on-costs-to-ratepayers-if-northwestern-energy-or-state-of-montana-purchase-colstrip-plant\_-may-2016-ff4e5df55aeb2937.pdf}}, publisher = {Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis}, url = {https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/resources/Memorandum-on-Costs-to-Ratepayers-if-NorthWestern-Energy-or-State-of-Montana-Purchase-Colstrip-Plant_-May-2016.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document ieefa-001717} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated