4-billion-bailout-in-the-buckeye-state-firstenergy-plan-will-cost-customers-for-years-to-come-_feb-2016-baf07350284b6ca2.pdf
Summary
This report analyzes FirstEnergy's proposed Retail Rate Stability Rider in Ohio, concluding that it would result in a net cost of $4 billion to ratepayers by subsidizing unprofitable, aging power plants.
Key insights
- FirstEnergy's proposal to use a Retail Rate Stability Rider (Rider RRS) would transfer the costs and risks of the W.H. Sammis, Clifty Creek, and Kyger Creek coal plants, as well as the Davis-Besse nuclear plant, to captive customers.
- While FirstEnergy claims the proposal would provide a net benefit of $561 million over eight years (June 1, 2016, to May 31, 2024), IEEFA estimates it would actually result in a net cost to ratepayers of approximately $4 billion.
- The proposal guarantees FirstEnergy and its shareholders a 10.38% return on equity each year, while the ratepayers bear all the operational and market risks.
- The economic viability of these plants is undermined by a precipitous decline in natural gas prices, increased competition from wind and solar PV, and relatively flat electric demand in the PJM region.
- FirstEnergy's financial projections are based on inflated forecasts for natural gas and electricity market prices; for example, it projected 2015 gas prices at $4.34 per MMBtu while actual prices were $2.63.
- The aging of the coal plants (with Clifty Creek and Kyger Creek units averaging 60 years old) is expected to lead to higher operating and maintenance costs and degraded performance.
- PJM's 2016 load forecasts show significant reductions in projected summer peak demands and energy usage compared to 2014 forecasts, further reducing the need for capacity from these plants.
- The report suggests that instead of a bailout, Ohio should implement an economic-transition plan to support workers and communities affected by the closure of obsolete plants, citing examples from New York and Chicago.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (n.d.). 4-billion-bailout-in-the-buckeye-state-firstenergy-plan-will-cost-customers-for-years-to-come-_feb-2016-baf07350284b6ca2.pdf. https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/resources/4-Billion-Bailout-in-the-Buckeye-State-FirstEnergy-Plan-Will-Cost-Customers-for-Years-to-Come-_Feb-2016.pdf
- Chicago
- Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis. 4-billion-bailout-in-the-buckeye-state-firstenergy-plan-will-cost-customers-for-years-to-come-_feb-2016-baf07350284b6ca2.pdf. n.d. https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/resources/4-Billion-Bailout-in-the-Buckeye-State-FirstEnergy-Plan-Will-Cost-Customers-for-Years-to-Come-_Feb-2016.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |author=Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis |title=4-billion-bailout-in-the-buckeye-state-firstenergy-plan-will-cost-customers-for-years-to-come-_feb-2016-baf07350284b6ca2.pdf |url=https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/resources/4-Billion-Bailout-in-the-Buckeye-State-FirstEnergy-Plan-Will-Cost-Customers-for-Years-to-Come-_Feb-2016.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document ieefa-000903)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{instituteforenergyeconomicsandfinancialanalysisnd4billionbailoutinthebuckeyestatefirstenergyplanwillcostcustomersforyearstocomefeb2016baf07350284b6ca2pdf, author = {{Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis}}, title = {{4-billion-bailout-in-the-buckeye-state-firstenergy-plan-will-cost-customers-for-years-to-come-\_feb-2016-baf07350284b6ca2.pdf}}, institution = {Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis}, url = {https://ieefa.org/sites/default/files/resources/4-Billion-Bailout-in-the-Buckeye-State-FirstEnergy-Plan-Will-Cost-Customers-for-Years-to-Come-_Feb-2016.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document ieefa-000903} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated