Six Real-World Rebuttals to Divestment Naysayers
Summary
This briefing contends that fossil fuel divestment is a sound fiduciary decision, asserting that fossil-free indexes have outperformed those containing fossil fuels over the last five years.
Key insights
- Arguments that divesting from fossil fuels leads to financial loss often rely on the assumption that the sector's strong performance over the last 50 years will continue, which violates Securities and Exchange Commission standards regarding past performance as an indicator of future results.
- The claim that transaction costs for converting funds would lower returns is based on a mechanistic theory of pricing that ignores the fact that fee structures are negotiable and can be adjusted to include portfolio rebalancing.
- Fossil fuel stocks are now considered speculative and require active management, making them too risky for small, passive-index-oriented investors who cannot afford to monitor industry changes closely.
- Divestment movements are complemented by other strategies, and some companies now identify the movement as a material risk in official filings; additionally, Moody's views the closure of old, inefficient coal plants as credit positive.
- Fossil-free indexes have demonstrated better performance than indexes containing fossil fuels over the previous five years.
- A study by Global Analytics claiming divestment would cause losses for the New York State Common Retirement Fund used misleading assumptions, such as replacing 8% annual yields with 3% or 6% returns, while ignoring the fund's actual 7% annual return target.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Sanzillo, T., & Hipple, K. (2018). Six Real-World Rebuttals to Divestment Naysayers. Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis. https://ieefa.org/resources/ieefa-update-six-real-world-rebuttals-divestment-naysayers
- Chicago
- Sanzillo, Tom, and Kathy Hipple. Six Real-World Rebuttals to Divestment Naysayers. Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis, 2018. https://ieefa.org/resources/ieefa-update-six-real-world-rebuttals-divestment-naysayers.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Sanzillo |first1=Tom |last2=Hipple |first2=Kathy |title=Six Real-World Rebuttals to Divestment Naysayers |publisher=Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis |date=12 September 2018 |url=https://ieefa.org/resources/ieefa-update-six-real-world-rebuttals-divestment-naysayers |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document ieefa-000100)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{sanzillo2018six, author = {Sanzillo, Tom and Hipple, Kathy}, title = {{Six Real-World Rebuttals to Divestment Naysayers}}, institution = {Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis}, year = {2018}, month = sep, url = {https://ieefa.org/resources/ieefa-update-six-real-world-rebuttals-divestment-naysayers}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document ieefa-000100} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated