Wertvoll für die Kreislaufwirtschaft, aber zu gut geschützt
Summary
The document argues that intellectual property rights—including patents, trade secrets, and copyrights—often hinder the circular economy by restricting access to repair information, limiting spare part availability, and creating legal uncertainty around product refurbishment. Based on a legal opinion from Mayer Brown, it suggests implementing 'repair clauses' in patent law, adopting a 'need-to-know' principle for data access via Digital Product Passports, and promoting open-hardware licenses to resolve these tensions without destroying innovation incentives.
Key insights
- Intellectual property rights create significant barriers to the circular economy by restricting the availability of spare parts and essential product information. Manufacturers often use trade secrets and patents to maintain monopolies on spare parts, leading to high prices or total unavailability, which discourages repair in favor of new purchases.
- A 'knowledge deficit' exists in circular value chains because manufacturers cite trade secrets or copyrights to avoid sharing information necessary for disassembly, refurbishment, and efficient recycling.
- Current laws create legal uncertainty for 'middle R' strategies (Repair, Refurbish, Remanufacture, Repurpose, Recycle). Specifically, the boundary between a legal repair and an illegal 'new manufacture' is unclear, making it risky to upgrade hardware or reuse components from defective products if they are patent-protected.
- The conflict between the need for information and the protection of trade secrets can be mitigated using a 'need-to-know' principle. By restricting access to sensitive data to specific authorized actors in the circular value chain, the status of a trade secret is preserved because the sharing does not constitute a public 'publication'.
- To resolve conflicts regarding product modification and spare parts, the document proposes introducing 'repair', 'refurbishment', and 'remanufacturing' clauses into intellectual property law, similar to existing design law exceptions. Such exceptions are deemed compatible with the WTO's TRIPS agreement because refurbished goods serve a different market than new products.
- Open-hardware licenses offer a pragmatic way for patent holders to allow the legal modification and improvement of products. However, this requires voluntary engagement from rights holders and is not a systemic solution for the entire market.
- Patents can slow the scaling of circular innovations, such as resource-efficient manufacturing processes, by granting exclusivity for up to 20 years. While compulsory licenses are a theoretical option, they are rarely granted and may undermine innovation incentives.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Denter, L. (n.d.). Wertvoll für die Kreislaufwirtschaft, aber zu gut geschützt. Germanwatch. https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/germanwatch_wertvoll_fuer_die_kreislaufwirtschaft_aber_zu_gut_geschuetzt_2024.pdf
- Chicago
- Denter, Luisa. Wertvoll für die Kreislaufwirtschaft, aber zu gut geschützt. Germanwatch, n.d. https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/germanwatch_wertvoll_fuer_die_kreislaufwirtschaft_aber_zu_gut_geschuetzt_2024.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Denter |first1=Luisa |title=Wertvoll für die Kreislaufwirtschaft, aber zu gut geschützt |publisher=Germanwatch |url=https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/germanwatch_wertvoll_fuer_die_kreislaufwirtschaft_aber_zu_gut_geschuetzt_2024.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document gerwat-001829)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{denterndwertvoll, author = {Denter, Luisa}, title = {{Wertvoll für die Kreislaufwirtschaft, aber zu gut geschützt}}, institution = {Germanwatch}, url = {https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/germanwatch_wertvoll_fuer_die_kreislaufwirtschaft_aber_zu_gut_geschuetzt_2024.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document gerwat-001829} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated