Gutachten zum Verstoß der zuständigen Ministerien und der Bundesregierung gegen die Pflicht zu Vorlage und Beschluss wirksamer Sofortprogramme (§ 8 Abs. 1, Abs. 2 KSG)
Summary
The legal opinion concludes that the immediate programs for the transport and building sectors failed to meet the requirements of § 8 Abs. 1 KSG because they did not ensure the adherence to annual emission limits in the following years. Furthermore, the federal government violated § 8 Abs. 2 KSG by failing to resolve necessary measures 'as quickly as possible', as no decision had been reached by the end of 2022 despite the legal urgency to correct the 2021 emission exceedances.
Key insights
- The transport and building sectors both exceeded their 2021 annual emission limits. The transport sector emitted approximately 148 million tonnes of CO2 equivalents, exceeding the limit by 3 million tonnes, while the building sector emitted 115 million tonnes, exceeding its limit by 2 million tonnes.
- The legal interpretation of § 8 Abs. 1 KSG requires that an immediate program must ensure the adherence to annual emission limits starting no later than the calendar year following the program's creation. For a 2021 violation, this means limits should have been met again by 2023 at the latest.
- The immediate program for the transport sector is legally insufficient because it only aimed to compensate for the 2021 deficit by 2030 rather than ensuring annual compliance. The proposed measures' reduction effects are far too low to counter projected exceedances for 2022-2024, and the calculations are not verifiable as the ministry provided no data on methodology or assumptions.
- The immediate program for the building sector is insufficient because it explicitly accepts further limit exceedances from 2022 to 2027, relying on a 'budget' approach to meet the 2030 target. Additionally, the Expert Council on Climate Issues (ERK) found the achievement of the assumed reduction potential to be only 'partially probable'.
- The federal government violated § 8 Abs. 2 KSG by failing to resolve measures 'as quickly as possible'. The document argues that this requirement generally necessitates a decision by the end of the calendar year following the reporting year (by the end of 2022 in this case) to avoid overlapping correction duties and to ensure timely impact.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Wollenteit, U. (2023). Gutachten zum Verstoß der zuständigen Ministerien und der Bundesregierung gegen die Pflicht zu Vorlage und Beschluss wirksamer Sofortprogramme (§ 8 Abs. 1, Abs. 2 KSG). Germanwatch. https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/germanwatch_rechtsgutachten_zu_klimaschutzsofortprogrammen_2023.pdf
- Chicago
- Wollenteit, Ulrich. Gutachten zum Verstoß der zuständigen Ministerien und der Bundesregierung gegen die Pflicht zu Vorlage und Beschluss wirksamer Sofortprogramme (§ 8 Abs. 1, Abs. 2 KSG). Germanwatch, 2023. https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/germanwatch_rechtsgutachten_zu_klimaschutzsofortprogrammen_2023.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Wollenteit |first1=Ulrich |title=Gutachten zum Verstoß der zuständigen Ministerien und der Bundesregierung gegen die Pflicht zu Vorlage und Beschluss wirksamer Sofortprogramme (§ 8 Abs. 1, Abs. 2 KSG) |publisher=Germanwatch |date=27 February 2023 |url=https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/germanwatch_rechtsgutachten_zu_klimaschutzsofortprogrammen_2023.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document gerwat-001777)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{wollenteit2023gutachten, author = {Wollenteit, Ulrich}, title = {{Gutachten zum Verstoß der zuständigen Ministerien und der Bundesregierung gegen die Pflicht zu Vorlage und Beschluss wirksamer Sofortprogramme (§ 8 Abs. 1, Abs. 2 KSG)}}, institution = {Germanwatch}, year = {2023}, month = feb, url = {https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/germanwatch_rechtsgutachten_zu_klimaschutzsofortprogrammen_2023.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document gerwat-001777} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated