Rechteinhaber*innen wirksam in Multi-Stakeholder-Initiativen einbeziehen
Summary
This position paper argues that German multi-stakeholder initiatives currently fail to sufficiently include rights holders, resulting in a discrepancy between those affected by corporate activities and those with influence over the initiatives' design.
Key insights
- There is a significant gap between the people affected by corporate activities and their representation and influence within German MSIs, where participants are primarily state, economic, and civil society actors from Germany.
- Many MSIs fail to meet the requirements of the UN Guiding Principles (UNGP) because they were not originally founded to implement human rights due diligence, and membership in an MSI does not guarantee that a company is fulfilling its individual due diligence obligations.
- The inclusion of rights holders is hindered by several systemic factors, including a lack of awareness of their value, power asymmetries, post-colonial value chain structures, and 'shrinking spaces' for civil society in some countries.
- Effective inclusion requires a spectrum of engagement ranging from target-group-specific information sharing and consultation to the integration of rights holders into the governance and decision-making structures of the MSI.
- The 'Bündnis für nachhaltige Textilien' (Partnership for Sustainable Textiles) is only at the beginning of including rights holders, with strong participation limited to specific voluntary projects like the Tamil Nadu initiative, while overall governance remains focused on Northern NGOs.
- The 'Forum Nachhaltiger Kakao' (Sustainable Cocoa Forum) has historically failed to systematically consult rights holders in its strategic direction, and its statutes limit cocoa producers to a guest or advisory status, excluding them from the governance structure.
- The 'Partnerschaft für nachhaltigen Orangensaft' (PANAO) involved various stakeholders in Brazil during its founding phase (2017-2019), but decision-making power still rests with the German steering committee, leaving Brazilian actors without formal decision-making authority.
- The 'NAP-Branchendialog Automobil' shows mixed results; while the overall level of inclusion is low, the pilot project for a cross-company grievance mechanism in Mexico has established a feedback group with Mexican NGOs, though it still relies heavily on Northern NGO networks for selection.
- To improve inclusion, MSIs must implement a roadmap including financial resources for Southern actors, administrative measures like translation into local languages, and the creation of protected feedback channels.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Bahn, E., Guhr, S., Heinz, R., Barros, A. M., Norpoth, J., Siever, L. L., & Rinn, T. (2022). Rechteinhaber*innen wirksam in Multi-Stakeholder-Initiativen einbeziehen. Germanwatch. https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/einbeziehung_von_rechteinhaberinnen_in_msi_final_v_11_2022_0.pdf
- Chicago
- Bahn, Evelyn, Sarah Guhr, Rebecca Heinz, Andréa Moraes Barros, Johannes Norpoth, Lara Louisa Siever, and Tobias Rinn. Rechteinhaber*innen wirksam in Multi-Stakeholder-Initiativen einbeziehen. Germanwatch, 2022. https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/einbeziehung_von_rechteinhaberinnen_in_msi_final_v_11_2022_0.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Bahn |first1=Evelyn |last2=Guhr |first2=Sarah |last3=Heinz |first3=Rebecca |last4=Barros |first4=Andréa Moraes |last5=Norpoth |first5=Johannes |last6=Siever |first6=Lara Louisa |last7=Rinn |first7=Tobias |title=Rechteinhaber*innen wirksam in Multi-Stakeholder-Initiativen einbeziehen |publisher=Germanwatch |date=November 2022 |url=https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/einbeziehung_von_rechteinhaberinnen_in_msi_final_v_11_2022_0.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document gerwat-001551)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{bahn2022rechteinhaberinnen, author = {Bahn, Evelyn and Guhr, Sarah and Heinz, Rebecca and Barros, Andréa Moraes and Norpoth, Johannes and Siever, Lara Louisa and Rinn, Tobias}, title = {{Rechteinhaber*innen wirksam in Multi-Stakeholder-Initiativen einbeziehen}}, institution = {Germanwatch}, year = {2022}, month = nov, url = {https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/einbeziehung_von_rechteinhaberinnen_in_msi_final_v_11_2022_0.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document gerwat-001551} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated