Zielkonflikte im energiepolitischen Zielviereck: Die dezentrale Energiewende zwischen Gerechtigkeit, Wirtschaftlichkeit, Versorgungssicherheit und Umweltschutz
Summary
This research paper argues that a successful decentralized energy transition requires a democratic discourse to resolve ten identified trade-offs, proposing a 'policy quadrangle' that elevates social justice to the same status as security, economy, and environment.
Key insights
- The authors propose an 'energy policy quadrangle' (energiepolitisches Zielviereck) that grants the goal of justice the same status as the established goals of security of supply, economic efficiency, and environmental compatibility.
- Energy Sharing is identified as a potent strategy to enable participation in the energy transition for all households, including those without property, and can stimulate local dynamics for renewable expansion.
- A regional balance of generation and consumption generally increases total system costs compared to a continental or national balance, as it requires significantly more flexibility capacity to manage fluctuations.
- The current auction model for wind energy has significantly hindered the participation of citizen energy cooperatives, leading to a shift in ownership toward funds and banks.
- Decentralized energy systems can increase resilience by reducing the impact of single-point failures and allowing regional cells to function independently during large-scale outages, though this introduces redundancies and cybersecurity risks.
- The document identifies a critical trade-off between the legitimacy gained through local participation and the need to accelerate the expansion of renewables to meet climate goals.
- Regional markets could theoretically provide efficient investment signals by creating high prices in demand centers, but they risk market power abuse and high regulatory costs.
- Siting wind turbines in less wind-rich regions can reduce redispatch costs and increase social acceptance by avoiding the over-concentration of plants in a few areas.
- Involving citizens at the regional planning stage, rather than just during project-specific approval processes, can accelerate the expansion of renewables by minimizing later conflicts.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Frank, D., Schmid, E., Bauknecht, D., Epp, J., Lehmann, P., Reutter, F., Scheidler, V., Vogel, M., & Wingenbach, M. (2022). Zielkonflikte im energiepolitischen Zielviereck: Die dezentrale Energiewende zwischen Gerechtigkeit, Wirtschaftlichkeit, Versorgungssicherheit und Umweltschutz. Germanwatch. https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/DEZ-Zielkonflikte-2022-Diskussionspapier_0.pdf
- Chicago
- Frank, David, Eva Schmid, Dierk Bauknecht, Julia Epp, Paul Lehmann, Felix Reutter, Viktoria Scheidler, Moritz Vogel, and Marion Wingenbach. Zielkonflikte im energiepolitischen Zielviereck: Die dezentrale Energiewende zwischen Gerechtigkeit, Wirtschaftlichkeit, Versorgungssicherheit und Umweltschutz. Germanwatch, 2022. https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/DEZ-Zielkonflikte-2022-Diskussionspapier_0.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Frank |first1=David |last2=Schmid |first2=Eva |last3=Bauknecht |first3=Dierk |last4=Epp |first4=Julia |last5=Lehmann |first5=Paul |last6=Reutter |first6=Felix |last7=Scheidler |first7=Viktoria |last8=Vogel |first8=Moritz |last9=Wingenbach |first9=Marion |title=Zielkonflikte im energiepolitischen Zielviereck: Die dezentrale Energiewende zwischen Gerechtigkeit, Wirtschaftlichkeit, Versorgungssicherheit und Umweltschutz |publisher=Germanwatch |date=January 2022 |url=https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/DEZ-Zielkonflikte-2022-Diskussionspapier_0.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document gerwat-001529)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{frank2022zielkonflikte, author = {Frank, David and Schmid, Eva and Bauknecht, Dierk and Epp, Julia and Lehmann, Paul and Reutter, Felix and Scheidler, Viktoria and Vogel, Moritz and Wingenbach, Marion}, title = {{Zielkonflikte im energiepolitischen Zielviereck: Die dezentrale Energiewende zwischen Gerechtigkeit, Wirtschaftlichkeit, Versorgungssicherheit und Umweltschutz}}, institution = {Germanwatch}, year = {2022}, month = jan, url = {https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/DEZ-Zielkonflikte-2022-Diskussionspapier_0.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document gerwat-001529} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated