Summary

AI-generated

This summary is written by a language model reading the source document. It is not the publisher's words and is not a substitute for the original.

Learn more about AI enrichment

The document argues that Germany can legally implement national regulatory measures to limit CO2 emissions from power plants, despite the EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS). It suggests that the EU ETS is currently ineffective due to a surplus of certificates and low prices. The author proposes specific measures, including a CO2 emission limit of 450 g/kWhel for new plants and a mandatory shutdown of existing plants after 40 years of operation, arguing these are compatible with EU primary law and the German constitution.

Key insights

AI-generated

These insights are written by a language model reading the source document. They are not the publisher's words and are not a substitute for the original.

Learn more about AI enrichment
  • The European Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) is described as highly ineffective because a massive surplus of certificates keeps prices too low to incentivize a shift to climate-friendly technologies. The document notes a surplus of "zwei Milliarden Emissionsrechtezertifikaten" (two billion emission certificates), with prices between five and seven euros per tonne of CO2, far below the more than 40 euros required for a 'fuel-switch'.
  • The author argues that national CO2 emission standards are admissible under EU law via the 'protection enhancement clause' (Art. 193 TFEU). This is justified by the 'precautionary principle' (Art. 191 TFEU) and the right of member states to determine their energy resource use and supply structure (Art. 194 TFEU), especially when the EU ETS fails to provide a steering effect.
  • The document proposes specific regulatory limits for new fossil-fuel power plants or those undergoing 'essential retrofits' (such as boiler replacement), suggesting a specific emission limit of "450 g/kWhel für CO2". This limit is designed to make coal-fired generation only possible if Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) technology is used.
  • For existing plants with a thermal input of 100 MW or more, the author proposes a maximum annual CO2 load of "3.351 Tonnen pro installiertem Megawatt elektrischer Netto-Leistung (t/MWel)" starting 35 years after commercial operation began, with a mandatory expiration of the operating permit after 40 years.
  • The proposed age limits and emission caps are argued to be constitutionally compatible with German law (specifically Art. 12 and 14 GG). The author contends that investments in coal plants are typically amortized within 15 to 25 years, meaning a 35-to-40-year window allows for reasonable profit realization and avoids the need for compensation.
  • To ensure grid stability and economic flexibility, the document suggests two mechanisms: allowing exceptions to emission limits if the Federal Network Agency (Bundesnetzagentur) identifies a threat to security of supply, and a 'fleet solution' allowing operators to transfer CO2 quotas between their own plants aged 35 to 40 years.

Cite the original document

APA
Ziehm, C. (2014). Der Moment der Wahrheit – Klima oder Kohle? Germanwatch. https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/publication/10230.pdf
Chicago
Ziehm, Cornelia. Der Moment der Wahrheit – Klima oder Kohle? Germanwatch, 2014. https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/publication/10230.pdf.
Wikipedia
{{cite report |last1=Ziehm |first1=Cornelia |title=Der Moment der Wahrheit – Klima oder Kohle? |publisher=Germanwatch |date=November 2014 |url=https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/publication/10230.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document gerwat-000651)}}
BibTeX
@techreport{ziehm2014der, author = {Ziehm, Cornelia}, title = {{Der Moment der Wahrheit – Klima oder Kohle?}}, institution = {Germanwatch}, year = {2014}, month = nov, url = {https://www.germanwatch.org/sites/default/files/publication/10230.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document gerwat-000651} }

Full text

Collected · Record updated