RE: CSOs response to ADB Private Sector Operations Department letter on 7 November 2022 regarding Vie Binh Duong Waste Management and Energy Efficiency Project (Project Number 5611)
Summary
GAIA and the NGO Forum on ADB challenge the ADB's approval of the Vie Binh Duong Waste Management and Energy Efficiency Project, specifically its WTE incineration component. They argue the project violates the ADB Energy Policy's waste hierarchy, lacks transparency regarding WTE guidance notes, and falsely claims to be a low-carbon, renewable energy source. The CSOs highlight severe risks from dioxins and toxic ash, and demand the removal of the incineration component and the public disclosure of ADB's WTE guidance notes.
Key insights
- The project is alleged to violate the ADB Energy Policy's waste hierarchy, which prioritizes waste reduction, reuse, and recycling over energy recovery and landfilling. The CSOs argue that the project treats WTE as necessary for circularity rather than a last resort, and that the lack of source-separation for feedstock means recyclables will be incinerated and compost may be contaminated.
- The ADB has not made its guidance note on WTE publicly available, which the CSOs claim prevents transparency and the ability of civil society to monitor whether projects comply with screening standards. GAIA asserts that simulation models in the guidance notes do not follow the waste management hierarchy.
- The CSOs dispute the claim that WTE incineration is a climate-mitigating or low-carbon activity, stating it releases fossil-carbon from plastics. They cite UNEP data indicating waste incineration emits 250–600 kg of fossil-CO2 per tonne of waste, and note that burning one tonne of plastic results in 1.43 tonnes of CO2e even when accounting for recovered energy.
- The project's claim of generating renewable energy is challenged because the WTE plant uses high calorific value feedstock, including fossil-based plastics, which the IPCC does not classify as renewable feedstock.
- There are significant concerns regarding the emission of dioxins and other Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs). The CSOs argue that the project's sampling standards are flawed because they only cover approximately 0.1% of yearly operating time and ignore 'Other Than Normal Operating Conditions' (OTNOC) like start-ups and shut-downs when emissions surge.
- The plan to use incineration fly ash and bottom ash for commercial ceramic bricks and tiles is criticized as hazardous. The CSOs state these residues contain heavy metals and POPs (including PCDD/Fs, PBDE, PCBs, PFAS) that can leach into the environment.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives (2022). RE: CSOs response to ADB Private Sector Operations Department letter on 7 November 2022 regarding Vie Binh Duong Waste Management and Energy Efficiency Project (Project Number 5611). https://www.no-burn.org/re-csos-response-to-adb-private-sector-operations-department-letter-on-7-november-2022-regarding-vie-binh-duong-waste-management-and-energy-efficiency-project-project-number-5611/
- Chicago
- Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives. RE: CSOs response to ADB Private Sector Operations Department letter on 7 November 2022 regarding Vie Binh Duong Waste Management and Energy Efficiency Project (Project Number 5611). 2022. https://www.no-burn.org/re-csos-response-to-adb-private-sector-operations-department-letter-on-7-november-2022-regarding-vie-binh-duong-waste-management-and-energy-efficiency-project-project-number-5611/.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite press release |author=Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives |title=RE: CSOs response to ADB Private Sector Operations Department letter on 7 November 2022 regarding Vie Binh Duong Waste Management and Energy Efficiency Project (Project Number 5611) |date=14 December 2022 |url=https://www.no-burn.org/re-csos-response-to-adb-private-sector-operations-department-letter-on-7-november-2022-regarding-vie-binh-duong-waste-management-and-energy-efficiency-project-project-number-5611/ |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document gaia-000130)}}
- BibTeX
- @misc{globalallianceforincineratoralternatives2022csos, author = {{Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives}}, title = {{RE: CSOs response to ADB Private Sector Operations Department letter on 7 November 2022 regarding Vie Binh Duong Waste Management and Energy Efficiency Project (Project Number 5611)}}, publisher = {Global Alliance for Incinerator Alternatives}, year = {2022}, month = dec, url = {https://www.no-burn.org/re-csos-response-to-adb-private-sector-operations-department-letter-on-7-november-2022-regarding-vie-binh-duong-waste-management-and-energy-efficiency-project-project-number-5611/}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document gaia-000130} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated