PETITIONERS’ EXCERPTS OF RECORD
Summary
This document is a legal record from a case in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit concerning the EPA's registration of the insecticide Sulfoxaflor. It includes an ecological risk assessment concluding low risk for most aquatic and terrestrial organisms, but identifying potential acute risks to birds and chronic risks to mammals. The record details significant disputes over the pesticide's impact on native bees, its carcinogenic potential, and the enforceability of label restrictions designed to protect pollinators.
Key insights
- Sulfoxaflor is a systemic insecticide and the only member of the sulfoxamine subclass of neonicotinoids. It acts as an agonist of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR), causing excitatory responses, tremors, paralysis, and death in target insects. It is effective against insects resistant to neonicotinoids like imidacloprid.
- The EPA's ecological risk assessment for Sulfoxaflor concludes that the potential for acute or chronic risk to fish, aquatic invertebrates, aquatic plants, and terrestrial plants is low, as risk quotient (RQ) values do not exceed levels of concern (LOC) for listed species.
- A potential for acute risk to birds was identified because acute, dose-based RQ values exceed the listed species LOC of 0.1 for at least one avian dietary category and size class across all uses. However, the EPA notes this finding is uncertain as it is based on a 'non-definitive' endpoint related to treatment-related increases in regurgitation.
- A potential for chronic risk to mammals was identified, with chronic dose-based RQ values up to 3.8 exceeding the listed species LOC of 0.1 for at least one mammalian dietary category and size class across all uses.
- The EPA classified Sulfoxaflor as having “Suggestive Evidence of Carcinogenic Potential” following studies in rats and mice that showed increases in liver tumors and preputial gland carcinomas.
- Developmental toxicity was observed in rats, where activation of the nAChR caused prolonged muscle contraction in unborn pups, leading to skeletal abnormalities or death by asphyxiation. The EPA concluded these effects are not likely relevant to humans due to pharmacodynamic differences in the nAChR receptor.
- The EPA reduced the FQPA Safety Factor from 10X to 1X for acute exposure to women of child-bearing age, arguing that the database is complete and the developmental effects are specific to the fetal rat isoform of the receptor.
- Public commenters expressed concern that the EPA's risk assessment for bees relied too heavily on Apis mellifera (honey bees) as a surrogate, ignoring the higher vulnerability of the approximately 4,000 species of native North American bees.
- The EPA responded to concerns about non-Apis bees by stating that it lacks standard toxicity testing protocols for these species and will continue to use Apis mellifera as a surrogate organism for bees in general.
- Petitioners and public commenters argued that label restrictions intended to protect pollinators (such as application timing) are unrealistic, unenforceable, and often ignored by applicators in the real world.
- The EPA maintains that its mitigation measures, including lowering application rates and prohibiting application during bloom for certain crops, are mandatory and enforceable.
- The EPA argues that the registration of Sulfoxaflor may reduce overall ecological risk because it is intended to replace older insecticide classes, such as organophosphates, carbamates, and pyrethroids, which present greater risks to non-target species.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Earthjustice (n.d.). PETITIONERS’ EXCERPTS OF RECORD. https://earthjustice.org/wp-content/uploads/honeybeesadrecord1.pdf
- Chicago
- Earthjustice. PETITIONERS’ EXCERPTS OF RECORD. n.d. https://earthjustice.org/wp-content/uploads/honeybeesadrecord1.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |author=Earthjustice |title=PETITIONERS’ EXCERPTS OF RECORD |url=https://earthjustice.org/wp-content/uploads/honeybeesadrecord1.pdf |access-date=17 August 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document earjust-001783)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{earthjusticendpetitioners, author = {{Earthjustice}}, title = {{PETITIONERS’ EXCERPTS OF RECORD}}, institution = {Earthjustice}, url = {https://earthjustice.org/wp-content/uploads/honeybeesadrecord1.pdf}, urldate = {2026-08-17}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document earjust-001783} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated