THE GERMAN COAL COMMISSION – A ROLE MODEL FOR TRANSFORMATIVE CHANGE?
Summary
The German Coal Commission reached a compromise in January 2019 to phase out coal by 2038, providing a case study on the use of multi-stakeholder commissions for sectoral transitions. While the process ensured stakeholder buy-in and regional representation, the briefing argues that the resulting timeline is not aligned with the Paris Agreement's 1.5-degree goal. Key lessons include the risk of using commissions to delegate political responsibility, the difficulty of negotiating climate ambition alongside financial compensation, and the necessity of aligning international finance with ambitious climate goals to ensure a Just Transition.
Key insights
- The German Coal Commission's final recommendations include a coal phase-out by 2038 at the latest, with a review in 2032 to see if this can be moved to 2035. It also proposes closing 12 GW of coal capacity by 2022, reducing total capacity to 17 GW by 2030, and investing €40 billion in lignite mining regions over 20 years.
- The phase-out trajectory recommended by the Commission is inconsistent with the Paris Agreement and lags behind other Western European nations. Furthermore, the potential for high compensation payments to utilities may discourage economically weaker coal-dependent countries from pursuing their own phase-outs.
- Multi-stakeholder commissions are effective for ensuring buy-in and legitimacy in polarized political environments, but their inclusive nature can hinder transformative change. When commissions include blocking minorities and lack a government-mandated ambitious goal, the result is often a hard-fought compromise rather than a transformative shift.
- There is a risk that governments use commissions to delegate political responsibility for contentious issues. The briefing suggests that commissions are more effective when mandated to explore multiple policy pathways to inform political decision-making, rather than being tasked with producing a single recommendation.
- The negotiation process was complicated by the attempt to simultaneously address climate ambition, implementation trajectories, and transition measures. This complexity, combined with the exclusion of vulnerable groups like youth, can lead to imbalances in how different priorities are weighted.
- For a Just Transition to be successful globally, domestic and international finance flows must align with ambitious climate goals. In the EU, the design of the next budget and its link to the EU Coal Regions in Transition Platform will be critical for socially just and economically sustainable transitions.
Cite the original document
- APA
- REITZENSTEIN, A., & POPP, R. (2019). THE GERMAN COAL COMMISSION – A ROLE MODEL FOR TRANSFORMATIVE CHANGE? E3G. https://www.e3g.org/wp-content/uploads/docs/E3G_2019_Briefing_German_Coal_Commission.pdf
- Chicago
- REITZENSTEIN, ALEXANDER, and REBEKKA POPP. THE GERMAN COAL COMMISSION – A ROLE MODEL FOR TRANSFORMATIVE CHANGE? E3G, 2019. https://www.e3g.org/wp-content/uploads/docs/E3G_2019_Briefing_German_Coal_Commission.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=REITZENSTEIN |first1=ALEXANDER |last2=POPP |first2=REBEKKA |title=THE GERMAN COAL COMMISSION – A ROLE MODEL FOR TRANSFORMATIVE CHANGE? |publisher=E3G |date=April 2019 |url=https://www.e3g.org/wp-content/uploads/docs/E3G_2019_Briefing_German_Coal_Commission.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document e3g-001034)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{reitzenstein2019german, author = {REITZENSTEIN, ALEXANDER and POPP, REBEKKA}, title = {{THE GERMAN COAL COMMISSION – A ROLE MODEL FOR TRANSFORMATIVE CHANGE?}}, institution = {E3G}, year = {2019}, month = apr, url = {https://www.e3g.org/wp-content/uploads/docs/E3G_2019_Briefing_German_Coal_Commission.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document e3g-001034} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated