Review of greenhouse gas emissions in SEA and EIA processes: Annex – SEA and EIA case studies
Summary
The document analyzes 20 SEA and EIA case studies, finding that while many provide comprehensive quantitative baselines, there is a frequent disconnect where this quantitative data is not carried through into the qualitative assessment of significance or the monitoring frameworks.
Key insights
- In many SEA case studies, such as the Fife SECAP and East Renfrewshire LDP2, there is a disconnect between the quantitative data provided in the environmental baseline and the qualitative nature of the assessment matrices, where quantified emissions reductions are not specified for individual actions.
- The Perth and Kinross Council Renewable and Low Carbon Energy Supplementary Guidance demonstrates a strong link between a quantified spatial baseline and monitoring indicators, yet the actual assessment matrices remain qualitative and lack detailed justification for scoring.
- The Draft Climate Change and Energy Strategies (2017) for Scotland exhibit a highly comprehensive and quantified environmental baseline, but the assessment of policies remains largely qualitative, reflecting the strategic nature of the high-level policy actions.
- The East Lothian Local Transport Strategy 2018 is noted for having a very limited environmental baseline regarding GHG emissions, lacking critical data on active travel, commuting patterns, and the transport sector's specific contribution to local emissions.
- In wind farm EIAs, such as Benbrack and Dell, the use of the Scottish Government's Carbon Calculator is a standard benefit, providing quantified 'payback periods' to determine when a project becomes a net avoider of emissions, although it may omit some construction-related emissions.
- The Port of Cromarty Firth Phase 4 Development EIA illustrates a method of determining significance by comparing project emissions (0.03% of annual CO2e) to total Scottish GHG emissions, concluding the impact was non-significant.
- The Madison Square Gardens London EIA is highlighted for its detailed quantitative assessment covering all project phases, and for adopting the IEMA guidance that all GHG emissions are considered significant and adverse, regardless of their small percentage of the national carbon budget.
- Across multiple case studies, such as the A90/A96 Haudagain Improvement Project and A9 Berriedale Braes, Transport Scotland's Carbon Management System (CMS) is used to ensure consistency in measuring embodied and direct emissions for road projects.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Underwood, S., Wright, J., Mallon, L., & Kaczor, K. (2021). Review of greenhouse gas emissions in SEA and EIA processes: Annex – SEA and EIA case studies. ClimateXChange. https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/review-of-greenhouse-gas-emissions-in-sea-and-eia-processes_case-study-annex-final-jan-21.pdf
- Chicago
- Underwood, Susanne, Joanna Wright, Lauren Mallon, and Karolina Kaczor. Review of greenhouse gas emissions in SEA and EIA processes: Annex – SEA and EIA case studies. ClimateXChange, 2021. https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/review-of-greenhouse-gas-emissions-in-sea-and-eia-processes_case-study-annex-final-jan-21.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Underwood |first1=Susanne |last2=Wright |first2=Joanna |last3=Mallon |first3=Lauren |last4=Kaczor |first4=Karolina |title=Review of greenhouse gas emissions in SEA and EIA processes: Annex – SEA and EIA case studies |publisher=ClimateXChange |date=2021 |url=https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/review-of-greenhouse-gas-emissions-in-sea-and-eia-processes_case-study-annex-final-jan-21.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document climex-000556)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{underwood2021review, author = {Underwood, Susanne and Wright, Joanna and Mallon, Lauren and Kaczor, Karolina}, title = {{Review of greenhouse gas emissions in SEA and EIA processes: Annex – SEA and EIA case studies}}, institution = {ClimateXChange}, year = {2021}, url = {https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/review-of-greenhouse-gas-emissions-in-sea-and-eia-processes_case-study-annex-final-jan-21.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document climex-000556} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated