A fair distribution of costs and benefits in Scotland’s Just Transition: findings from deliberative research
Summary
The report details public views on achieving a just transition to net zero in Scotland across three sectors. Participants advocated for an equitable approach where costs are shared between the Scottish Government, businesses, and citizens, but distributed based on ability to pay and control over emissions. Key recommendations include progressive taxation, targeted support for low-income and rural populations, and a 'carrot and stick' approach to behaviour change, prioritising infrastructure investment and clear communication before introducing penalties.
Key insights
- Participants concluded that the costs of transitioning to net zero should be shared among the Scottish Government, businesses, and citizens, but not equally. They advocated for an equitable approach where contributions are based on "the amount of control someone has over their level of emissions", "the availability of lower carbon alternatives", and "their ability to pay".
- There was broad support for using progressive taxation to fund the transition, with the principle that higher-income individuals and businesses should contribute more. Some participants specifically suggested taxing larger, profit-making businesses, landowners, or high-carbon products, provided sustainable alternatives are affordable.
- Participants emphasised that those least able to afford the transition must be protected through exemptions and targeted support. This includes low-income individuals, people with health conditions or disabilities, and those in rural communities who face higher barriers, such as a lack of public transport infrastructure.
- A 'carrot and stick' approach was broadly supported, where incentives (carrots) like grants and subsidies are introduced first to encourage low-carbon choices, followed by restrictions or charges (sticks) only once viable alternatives are readily available.
- Regarding the transport sector, participants felt that Road User Charging (RUC) would only be fair if it avoided a blanket approach and included concessions for low-income groups, disabled people, the elderly, and rural residents. They stressed that improved public transport infrastructure must be a prerequisite for any RUC implementation.
- In the built environment sector, participants argued that those who profit from buildings, such as construction businesses and owners of multiple properties, should bear the costs of decarbonisation. For the heat transition, they suggested that while support should be available to all, the highest levels of government funding should be reserved for low-income households and those with older properties.
- For the land use and agriculture sector, participants agreed that costs should be shared between the Scottish Government, businesses (including farmers and supermarkets), consumers, and landowners. They recommended subsidising smaller farms with lower incomes and providing sufficient time for farmers to adapt before introducing new taxes.
- The research highlighted a need for clear, transparent communication and ongoing public engagement. Participants expressed a desire for an apolitical, science-led body to oversee the transition and decide on fair payment systems to ensure accountability and consistency.
- Participants' views evolved during the deliberative process; while many initially believed those who emit the most should pay the most, they later concluded this would be unfair to those with limited control over their emissions, such as rural residents or certain businesses.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Abernethy, S., Simpson, E., & Mulholland, C. (2024). A fair distribution of costs and benefits in Scotland’s Just Transition: findings from deliberative research. ClimateXChange. https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/CXC-A-fair-distribution-of-costs-and-benefits-in-Scotlands-Just-Transition-May-2024.pdf
- Chicago
- Abernethy, Sally, Erin Simpson, and Ciaran Mulholland. A fair distribution of costs and benefits in Scotland’s Just Transition: findings from deliberative research. ClimateXChange, 2024. https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/CXC-A-fair-distribution-of-costs-and-benefits-in-Scotlands-Just-Transition-May-2024.pdf.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Abernethy |first1=Sally |last2=Simpson |first2=Erin |last3=Mulholland |first3=Ciaran |title=A fair distribution of costs and benefits in Scotland’s Just Transition: findings from deliberative research |publisher=ClimateXChange |date=May 2024 |url=https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/CXC-A-fair-distribution-of-costs-and-benefits-in-Scotlands-Just-Transition-May-2024.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document climex-000227)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{abernethy2024fair, author = {Abernethy, Sally and Simpson, Erin and Mulholland, Ciaran}, title = {{A fair distribution of costs and benefits in Scotland’s Just Transition: findings from deliberative research}}, institution = {ClimateXChange}, year = {2024}, month = may, url = {https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/CXC-A-fair-distribution-of-costs-and-benefits-in-Scotlands-Just-Transition-May-2024.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document climex-000227} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated