Involving communities in deliberation: A study of 3 citizens’ juries on onshore wind farms in Scotland

Report an error

Summary

AI-generated

This summary is written by a language model reading the source document. It is not the publisher's words and is not a substitute for the original.

Learn more about AI enrichment

The report details a mixed-methods study of three citizens' juries in Coldstream, Helensburgh, and Aberfeldy, focusing on the operational challenges of organizing mini-publics and the resulting impact on juror learning and opinion change. It evaluates the quality of deliberation and the principles formulated by jurors to guide wind farm development, while offering recommendations for institutionalizing deliberative democracy in Scotland.

Key insights

AI-generated

These insights are written by a language model reading the source document. They are not the publisher's words and are not a substitute for the original.

Learn more about AI enrichment
  • The three citizens' juries produced a set of guiding principles for wind farm development that overlapped across six primary themes: the desirable energy mix for Scotland, characteristics of required evidence, range of positive and negative impacts, public responsibility in reducing energy use, limits to development, and the distribution of benefits.
  • Jurors' opinions on wind farms were significantly influenced by the diversity of the group; juries with a wide range of perspectives (Coldstream and Aberfeldy) tended to moderate their views, whereas the more homogeneous jury in Helensburgh experienced group polarisation, shifting toward more extreme negative views.
  • The Information Phase (Day 1) was the most significant period for factual knowledge gain and initial preference change, while the Deliberation Phase (Day 2) focused more on understanding nuances, trade-offs, and the complexity of the debate.
  • The study found that providing financial compensation (£70 for Day 1 and £100 for Day 2) was essential for ensuring inclusive participation by removing barriers for those with fewer resources, such as carers or the self-employed.
  • Deliberative quality was high across the juries, with 91% of jurors feeling able to express their views without coercion, and a strong overall sense of respect and commitment to the common good over self-interest.
  • The research identified three 'outspoken' juror archetypes—the 'contrarian', the 'professional', and the 'sage'—who can either enhance scrutiny or hinder inclusion depending on their communication style and the facilitator's management.
  • The process fostered significant increases in jurors' self-efficacy and civic skills, with many participants reporting increased confidence in their ability to participate in public deliberation and influence outcomes.
  • The study highlights that the two-day timeframe was insufficient for a real decision-making process, as it limited the jurors' ability to fully unpack contradictions, trade-offs, and implementation details of their agreed principles.
  • Witnesses' rhetorical styles—combining ethos, pathos, and logos—had a substantial impact on juror perception, with passionate and emotionally compelling delivery sometimes outweighing the perceived reliability of the evidence.
  • The use of 'Information Officers' who could play 'devil's advocate' was effective in disrupting uncritical consensus and forcing jurors to justify their arguments more rigorously.

Cite the original document

APA
Roberts, J., & Escobar, O. (2015). Involving communities in deliberation: A study of 3 citizens’ juries on onshore wind farms in Scotland. ClimateXChange. https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/citizens_juries_-_full_report.pdf
Chicago
Roberts, Jennifer, and Oliver Escobar. Involving communities in deliberation: A study of 3 citizens’ juries on onshore wind farms in Scotland. ClimateXChange, 2015. https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/citizens_juries_-_full_report.pdf.
Wikipedia
{{cite report |last1=Roberts |first1=Jennifer |last2=Escobar |first2=Oliver |title=Involving communities in deliberation: A study of 3 citizens’ juries on onshore wind farms in Scotland |publisher=ClimateXChange |date=May 2015 |url=https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/citizens_juries_-_full_report.pdf |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document climex-000190)}}
BibTeX
@techreport{roberts2015involving, author = {Roberts, Jennifer and Escobar, Oliver}, title = {{Involving communities in deliberation: A study of 3 citizens’ juries on onshore wind farms in Scotland}}, institution = {ClimateXChange}, year = {2015}, month = may, url = {https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/citizens_juries_-_full_report.pdf}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document climex-000190} }

Full text

Collected · Record updated