A fair distribution of costs and benefits in Scotland’s Just Transition: findings from deliberative research
Summary
The report details public perspectives on achieving a 'just transition' to net zero in Scotland across three key sectors. Participants advocated for an equitable distribution of costs where the Scottish Government, businesses, and citizens all contribute, but based on their ability to pay and their level of control over emissions. Key findings emphasize the need for progressive taxation, targeted support for low-income and rural populations, and a 'carrot and stick' approach where incentives precede penalties. Sector-specific conclusions highlight the necessity of improved public transport infrastructure before introducing road user charging and the need for varied government funding for home energy retrofitting based on property age and household income.
Key insights
- Participants advocated for an equitable approach to funding the net zero transition, asserting that while everyone should contribute, the amount should vary based on their ability to pay, the availability of low-carbon alternatives, and their level of control over emissions.
- There is broad public support for using progressive taxation to fund the transition, specifically targeting higher-income individuals and profit-making businesses.
- A 'carrot and stick' strategy was recommended, where positive incentives (carrots) are introduced first to encourage low-carbon choices, followed by restrictions or charges (sticks) only once viable alternatives are readily available.
- In the transport sector, participants concluded that any Road User Charging (RUC) would be unfair without first establishing reliable, integrated public transport infrastructure, particularly in rural areas.
- For the built environment, participants suggested that those who profit from buildings, such as construction businesses and multiple-property owners, should bear a significant share of the costs for lowering carbon emissions.
- Regarding the heat transition in homes, participants recommended a tiered funding system where all households receive some support, but those on low incomes and those with older properties receive the most government funding.
- In the land and agriculture sector, participants agreed that costs should be shared between the Scottish Government, businesses (including supermarkets), farmers, and consumers, with specific subsidies favoring smaller farms.
- Participants expressed a strong need for the Scottish Government to establish a non-political, independent body to lead the just transition based on science and evidence rather than politics.
- The research highlighted that an emissions-based payment system ('those who emit the most pay the most') was perceived as unfair because it penalizes those who lack the means or the infrastructure to switch to low-carbon alternatives.
- Participants emphasized that the timing of policies is critical; they felt deadlines for energy efficiency improvements (e.g., 2028 for landlords) were too aggressive, while the 2045 deadline for clean heating systems was too distant to motivate immediate action.
Cite the original document
- APA
- ClimateXChange (2024). A fair distribution of costs and benefits in Scotland’s Just Transition: findings from deliberative research. https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/publications/a-fair-distribution-of-costs-and-benefits-in-scotlands-just-transition-findings-from-deliberative-research/
- Chicago
- ClimateXChange. A fair distribution of costs and benefits in Scotland’s Just Transition: findings from deliberative research. 2024. https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/publications/a-fair-distribution-of-costs-and-benefits-in-scotlands-just-transition-findings-from-deliberative-research/.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |author=ClimateXChange |title=A fair distribution of costs and benefits in Scotland’s Just Transition: findings from deliberative research |date=12 December 2024 |url=https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/publications/a-fair-distribution-of-costs-and-benefits-in-scotlands-just-transition-findings-from-deliberative-research/ |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document climex-000064)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{climatexchange2024fair, author = {{ClimateXChange}}, title = {{A fair distribution of costs and benefits in Scotland’s Just Transition: findings from deliberative research}}, institution = {ClimateXChange}, year = {2024}, month = dec, url = {https://www.climatexchange.org.uk/publications/a-fair-distribution-of-costs-and-benefits-in-scotlands-just-transition-findings-from-deliberative-research/}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document climex-000064} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated