Why Offsets Are Not a Viable Alternative to Cutting Emissions
Summary
This report argues that carbon offsets, especially land-based ones, are fundamentally flawed due to issues of permanence and additionality, and that their unlimited use in Australia's Safeguard Mechanism risks enabling the continued expansion of fossil fuel production.
Key insights
- Land-based carbon offsets are inherently reversible and cannot guarantee the long-term sequestration required to offset fossil fuel emissions, which can remain in the atmosphere for thousands of years.
- The Australian Government's proposed unlimited use of Australian carbon credit units (ACCUs) under the Safeguard Mechanism is likely to sanction the continuation and expansion of fossil fuel production.
- Offsetting one tonne of CO2 equivalent from Australian liquefied natural gas (LNG) production can effectively result in 8.4 tonnes of global emissions when accounting for transport and final use.
- Offsetting one tonne of emissions from an average Australian coal mine can lead to 58-67 tonnes of global emissions.
- The Human Induced Regeneration (HIR) method, which accounts for nearly 30% of issued ACCUs, is criticized for lacking genuineness and additionality, as vegetation growth often correlates more strongly with rainfall than project activities.
- Australia's definition of permanence (100 years) is critically insufficient because approximately 40% of fossil CO2 emissions remain in the atmosphere after a century.
- The use of inexpensive offsets can lead to 'carbon lock-in,' where companies avoid investing in low-carbon technology and instead maintain polluting infrastructure.
- Land-based offsets are vulnerable to climate-driven risks, such as the 2019/20 Australian bushfires, which caused ecosystem carbon losses that exceeded Australia's fossil fuel emissions for that year.
- Using CO2 offsets to facilitate continued methane emissions is flawed because methane's high short-term warming potential creates a time-lag where temperatures remain elevated before the offset's cooling effect grows.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Wilson, R., Hare, B., Grant, N., & Houlie, T. (2023). Why Offsets Are Not a Viable Alternative to Cutting Emissions. Climate Analytics. https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/why_offsets_are_not_a_viable_alternative_to_cutting_emissions.pdf?v=1697123932
- Chicago
- Wilson, Ryan, Bill Hare, Neil Grant, and Thomas Houlie. Why Offsets Are Not a Viable Alternative to Cutting Emissions. Climate Analytics, 2023. https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/why_offsets_are_not_a_viable_alternative_to_cutting_emissions.pdf?v=1697123932.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Wilson |first1=Ryan |last2=Hare |first2=Bill |last3=Grant |first3=Neil |last4=Houlie |first4=Thomas |title=Why Offsets Are Not a Viable Alternative to Cutting Emissions |publisher=Climate Analytics |date=February 2023 |url=https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/why_offsets_are_not_a_viable_alternative_to_cutting_emissions.pdf?v=1697123932 |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document climanal-000635)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{wilson2023why, author = {Wilson, Ryan and Hare, Bill and Grant, Neil and Houlie, Thomas}, title = {{Why Offsets Are Not a Viable Alternative to Cutting Emissions}}, institution = {Climate Analytics}, year = {2023}, month = feb, url = {https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/why_offsets_are_not_a_viable_alternative_to_cutting_emissions.pdf?v=1697123932}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document climanal-000635} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated