Emissions Impossible
Summary
The report finds that CSIRO GISERA significantly underestimated the emissions from the Beetaloo project, estimating that actual emissions could be up to 84% higher for annual onshore emissions and nearly 1.5 times Australia's 2021 emissions for cumulative totals over 25 years.
Key insights
- CSIRO GISERA underestimated emissions across the Beetaloo project, including methane leakage, upstream emissions intensity, and LNG production emissions. The report estimates these emissions could add up to 11% of Australia's 2021 emissions.
- The methane loss rate assumed by CSIRO GISERA is underestimated by at least 56%, with the report suggesting a likely range of 0.7-1% compared to a production volume weighted loss rate of 2.6% observed in similar US shale gas activities.
- LNG liquefaction emissions intensity was underestimated by at least half; the report estimates the LNG made with Beetaloo shale gas has an intensity of around 21.9 kgCO2e/GJ, nearly twice the CSIRO GISERA estimate.
- Annual onshore emissions are underestimated by up to 84% across the scenarios used, with cumulative total emissions over 25 years (including overseas) estimated to be close to 1.5 times Australia's 2021 emissions.
- Tamboran Resources' plan for a 6.6 million tonnes per annum LNG plant at Middle Arm would generate emissions equivalent to 2-3% of Australia's 2021 emissions, while an expansion to 20 million tonnes per annum would generate 10-13% of Australia's 2021 emissions.
- The report argues that CSIRO GISERA overestimated the supply of land-based offsets in Australia by using liberal assumptions, suggesting that at a carbon price of $90 per tCO2e, there would be enough potential to offset the entirety of Australia's 2021 emissions.
- The viability of blue hydrogen and carbon capture and storage (CCS) is significantly exaggerated, as no commercially operational facility has achieved the 90% capture rate assumed by CSIRO GISERA.
- Up to 42% of offsets for a large-scale development scenario would need to be sourced internationally, which is currently not possible under Safeguard Mechanism regulations.
Cite the original document
- APA
- Houlie, T., & Hare, B. (2023). Emissions Impossible. Climate Analytics. https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/emissions_impossible.pdf?v=1698659237
- Chicago
- Houlie, Thomas, and Bill Hare. Emissions Impossible. Climate Analytics, 2023. https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/emissions_impossible.pdf?v=1698659237.
- Wikipedia
- {{cite report |last1=Houlie |first1=Thomas |last2=Hare |first2=Bill |title=Emissions Impossible |publisher=Climate Analytics |date=October 2023 |url=https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/emissions_impossible.pdf?v=1698659237 |access-date=5 November 2026 |via=Climate Insights Directory (document climanal-000458)}}
- BibTeX
- @techreport{houlie2023emissions, author = {Houlie, Thomas and Hare, Bill}, title = {{Emissions Impossible}}, institution = {Climate Analytics}, year = {2023}, month = oct, url = {https://ca1-clm.edcdn.com/assets/emissions_impossible.pdf?v=1698659237}, urldate = {2026-11-05}, note = {Indexed by Climate Insights Directory, document climanal-000458} }
Full text
Collected · Record updated